Simplicissimus

Pour mémoire, sur Ameli.fr
Mammographie de dépistage du cancer du sein - ameli-santé
▻http://www.ameli-sante.fr/cancer-du-sein/depistage-cancer-du-sein.html

Une femme sur huit développe un cancer du sein au cours de sa vie. C’est entre 50 et 74 ans que les femmes sont le plus exposées. Il est donc important qu’elles bénéficient de la mammographie de dépistage : un moyen efficace, simple et gratuit pour détecter un cancer du sein le plus tôt possible.

Wéé, #bonne_nouvelle ! Résumé : mieux vaut se faire palper les seins régulièrement que de souffrir cet écrasement médicalisé ! #cancer #mammographie #technologie_médicale #business

http://www.lexpress.fr/pictures/124/63933.jpg

Cela me rappelle une sage femme qui voulait absolument installer un monitoring pour une naissance à la maison alors qu’avec un simple #stéthoscope_en_bois elle avait entendu que l’enfant était une fille. Il faut donc plus de gynécologues, des formations spécifiques et surtout redonner de la confiance à la pratique médical plutôt qu’aux robots.

Proponents of mammograms often point out that women whose breast cancer is diagnosed by mammography alone live longer than those whose cancer is diagnosed by physical exam. This study found that as well, but the apparent advantage was illusory, the researchers concluded. For one thing, if a cancer is sufficiently aggressive and resistant to treatment it will likely prove fatal no matter when it is detected. Finding it in 2011 by physical exam, as opposed to 2007 by mammogram, simply means that the woman lives longer knowing that she has cancer, not that she lives longer overall.

Mammograms, the study found, increase perceived survival time without affecting the course of the disease.

▻http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/02/12/us-mammograms-idUSBREA1B1RJ20140212

#mammographie, la #stratégie_du_doute à l’œuvre, sur FoxNews. Ça n’a pas loupé, dès le titre Controversial study

Controversial mammogram study : What you need to know | Fox News
▻http://www.foxnews.com/health/2014/03/03/controversial-mammogram-study-what-need-to-know

While the study authors say the women were randomly placed in either the mammogram group or the control group, some members of the medical community claim that, after examining the women at the onset of the study, nurses may have put women with larger cancers into the mammogram group so they would receive better care and improve their odds of survival, says Dr. Marisa Weiss, president and founder of Breastcancer.org

Le site en question, sous des aspects balancés, incite vivement et « scientifiquement » à recourir à la mammographie.
Ce qu’il faut retenir sur le sujet d’après ce site « objectif » (je n’ai retenu que les titres)
Mammography : Benefits, Risks, What You Need to Know
▻http://www.breastcancer.org/symptoms/testing/types/mammograms/benefits_risks

Five important things to know about mammograms
1. They can save your life.
2. Don’t be afraid.
3. Get the best quality you can. ults.
4. Mammography is our most powerful breast cancer detection tool.
5. An unusual result requiring further testing does not always mean you have breast cancer.

Suivent (retour à FoxNews) d’autres arguments tout aussi attendus… et la qualité de la vie ? et le progrès technique ? en plus ça veut rien dire ! et c’est sans danger !

Other Issues
Even if this new research were based on a truly randomized trial, there are still some issues with it, says Weiss. For one thing, it looks only at survival—and not at other factors like quality of life.
(…)
Technology has also advanced quite a bit since the data was collected for this study.
(…)
As for the issue of over-diagnoses—and the fact that study authors say one in five of the tumors detected by mammography fall into this category—Weiss says there’s no one medical definition as to what that means exactly.
(…)
That said, the risk associated with getting a mammogram—namely, a small amount of exposure to radiation (about the same amount you’d get by getting an X-ray at your dentist’s office)—is minimal.

DONC…

So at this point, Weiss encourages all women over the age of 40 to keep their yearly mammogram appointment. “It’s irresponsible to say mammography doesn’t lead to improved survival based on this study,” says Weiss.

On vous l’avait bien dit : ce sont des chercheurs, ils sont irresponsables !

Méta-étude sur plusieurs types de cancer ▻http://seenthis.net/messages/388041