Why Saad Hariri Had That Strange Sojourn in Saudi Arabia

/saudi-arabia-saad-hariri-mohammed-bin-s

  • L’aspect le plus choquant de l’article du NY Times qui revient sur l’affaire Saad Hariri, que je vois assez allègrement présenté comme un scoop sur Twitter, c’est qu’il s’agit essentiellement d’une reprise des infos qu’Al Akhbar avait sorties au moment même des événements :
    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/24/world/middleeast/saudi-arabia-saad-hariri-mohammed-bin-salman-lebanon.html

    But instead he was stripped of his cellphones, separated from all but one of his usual cluster of bodyguards, and shoved and insulted by Saudi security officers. Then came the ultimate indignity: He was handed a prewritten resignation speech and forced to read it on Saudi television.

    Dans le Akhbar :
    http://al-akhbar.com/node/286011

    وبحسب المصادر، فان الجهات الامنية السعودية صادرت الهواتف الموجودة في حوزة الحريري وفريقه الامني. وتم تخيير أعضاء الفريق الامني إن كانوا يريدون المغادرة الى بيروت، وانه في هذه الحالة لن يكون بمقدور من يغادر المجمع ان يعود اليه مجدداً. وبناء على طلب الحريري، انتقل اربعة من مرافقيه بقيادة الضابط محمد دياب الى منزله للبقاء مع زوجته وأولاده، فيما بقي مع الحريري، في الفيلا نفسها، رئيس حرسه عبد العرب وأحد مساعديه الشخصيين. وأُبلغ الجميع بقواعد الاقامة لناحية عدم التحرك داخل الفندق وعدم التواصل مع الامنيين والموظفين، وتم ربطهم بضابط أمن سعودي في مكتب قريب، حيث يمكنهم التوجه مرات عدة في اليوم لتفقد هواتفهم، على ان ينحصر استعمالها في الرد على الرسائل التي تردهم عبر تطبيقات كـ«واتساب» وخلافه، وسمح لهم باجراء اتصالات هاتفية على ألا تشمل اي نقاش حول مكان اقامتهم وظروفها، تحت طائلة الحرمان من التواصل مرة جديدة.

    Que j’avais cité ici (7 novembre dernier) :
    https://seenthis.net/messages/642902

    Selon Ibrahim al-Amine du Akhbar, la « réception » de Saad Hariri à Riyad n’a pas ressemblé à l’accueil d’un Premiere ministre libanais, mais bien plutôt à l’arrestation d’un ressortitant séoudien. Retenu, téléphone confisqué, séparé de sa famille, interrogé comme « témoin » sur des histoires de corruption…

    Et bien entendu, le NY Times ne cite à aucun moment le Akbar, ce qui me semble assez emblématique de la façon de travailler des grands médias concernant la région.

  • Why Saad Hariri Had That Strange Sojourn in Saudi Arabia - The New York Times
    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/24/world/middleeast/saudi-arabia-saad-hariri-mohammed-bin-salman-lebanon.html

    Pas de trève des confiseurs aux USA ! Etrange offensive médiatique contre MbS, le tout daté du 24 décembre.

    Dans cet article du NYT (pas fracassant) qui relate la détention de Hariri en Arabie saoudite :

    As bizarre as the episode was, it was just one chapter in the story of Prince Mohammed, the ambitious young heir apparent determined to shake up the power structure not just of his own country but of the entire region.

    Dans le Washington Post (où il est décrit comme “le prince de l’hypocrisiehttps://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/saudi-arabias-crown-prince-of-hypocrisy/2017/12/24/b331025a-dc3f-11e7-b1a8-62589434a581_story.html:
    If he is truly interested in demonstrating enlightened and modern leadership, he should unlock the prison doors behind which he and his predecessors have unjustly jailed people of creativity, especially writers critical of the regime and intolerant religious hard-liners. Recently, he oversaw a crackdown that swept up influential clerics, activists, journalists and writers on vague charges of endangering national security. Allowing these voices to thrive and exist in the open would be a real contribution to the kind of society he says he wants. In particular, he should arrange an immediate pardon for blogger Raif Badawi, serving a 10-year jail sentence in the kingdom for the crime of free expression. Mr. Badawi offended hard-liners when he wrote that he longed for a more liberal Saudi society, saying, “Liberalism simply means, live and let live.”

    Opening Mr. Badawi’s cell door would do more to change Saudi Arabia than purchasing a fancy yacht and a villa in France.

    Et, Newsweek en remet une couche sur le Yémen notamment : But by far the biggest warning sign that Saudi Arabia is not ready to take human rights seriously is what it is doing in neighboring Yemen.

    “Earlier in November the U.N. warned that Yemen is on the brink of famine on a scale that the world has not seen in decades. This has been caused in no small part by the actions of the Saudi Arabia-led coalition fighting in the country.

    Since early November, Saudi Arabia has tightened a blockade preventing nearly all food and life-saving aid from reaching an already starving and battered nation. An estimated 130 Yemeni children are dying every day, according to Save the Children.

    Though key access routes have since been reopened, there is little evidence that enough critically needed aid is being allowed in or guarantees that it will not be tightened again following the Huthis’ control of Sana’a. There certainly has been an uptick in air strikes by the Saudi-led coalition in December.

    All parties to the conflict have crimes to answer for, but in its fight against Huthi rebels in Yemen, Saudi Arabia has decided that the collective punishment of Yemeni civilians is an acceptable tactic in war. It is not.

    The Saudi Arabian authorities are not keen for the outside world to see how they are waging this war. Yet the pictures are starting to trickle out. It is these images, as well as those of the real reformers in Saudi Arabia who are languishing behind bars, that we should keep in mind next time we think about casually endorsing the new Crown Prince’s efforts to bring about reform.”

    Et Newsweek en remet une couche sur le Yémen notamment, sous le titre “Les nouveaux habits de l’emperuer” http://www.newsweek.com/saudi-arabia-and-emperors-new-clothes-758219 :
    But by far the biggest warning sign that Saudi Arabia is not ready to take human rights seriously is what it is doing in neighboring Yemen.

    Earlier in November the U.N. warned that Yemen is on the brink of famine on a scale that the world has not seen in decades. This has been caused in no small part by the actions of the Saudi Arabia-led coalition fighting in the country.

    Since early November, Saudi Arabia has tightened a blockade preventing nearly all food and life-saving aid from reaching an already starving and battered nation. An estimated 130 Yemeni children are dying every day, according to Save the Children.

    Though key access routes have since been reopened, there is little evidence that enough critically needed aid is being allowed in or guarantees that it will not be tightened again following the Huthis’ control of Sana’a. There certainly has been an uptick in air strikes by the Saudi-led coalition in December.

    All parties to the conflict have crimes to answer for, but in its fight against Huthi rebels in Yemen, Saudi Arabia has decided that the collective punishment of Yemeni civilians is an acceptable tactic in war. It is not.

    The Saudi Arabian authorities are not keen for the outside world to see how they are waging this war. Yet the pictures are starting to trickle out. It is these images, as well as those of the real reformers in Saudi Arabia who are languishing behind bars, that we should keep in mind next time we think about casually endorsing the new Crown Prince’s efforts to bring about reform."

    #arabie_saoudite