/post

  • More deaths, fewer arrivals: Migration to Europe is becoming increasingly lethal
    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/72297/more-deaths-fewer-arrivals-migration-to-europe-is-becoming-increasingl

    More deaths, fewer arrivals: Migration to Europe is becoming increasingly lethal

    Even while arrivals to European countries keep decreasing, the number of people who have died trying to reach Europe has been on the rise this year, new data by the International Organization for Migration (IOM) shows. Another trend is an uptick in so-called invisible deaths.

    During the first six months of the year, 1,570 people have died on sea routes trying to reach European shores. That’s a 27 percent increase over last year, when 1,232 perished during the same period, according to new data released by UN migration agency IOM on Wednesday (July 8).

    The increase comes as the number of irregular arrivals to EU countries continues to decline: Last year, EU border agency Frontex recorded the lowest annual total since 2021 with just under 178,000 irregular entries at the EU’s external borders.

    This year, the trend continued: Frontex data published in mid-May showed a 40 percent year-on-year drop for the first four months of 2026.

  • Actualités de l’Union Européenne - Octobre-Décembre 2025
    ▻https://migreurop.org/article3514.html

    Dans le cadre de sa mission de volontariat avec Migreurop en partenariat avec Euromed Droits à Bruxelles (2025-2026), Jeanne Olivet publie une chronique trimestrielle dans laquelle elle résume les actualités des politiques migratoires européennes. Période octobre-décembre 2025 : Le 10 décembre 2025, la Commission européenne accueille à Bruxelles la Conférence internationale 2025 de l’Alliance mondiale pour lutter contre “le trafic illicite de migrants”, rapporte Politico. Plus de 80 (…) #Travaux_des_volontaires

    ▻https://www.politico.eu/newsletter/brussels-playbook/trumps-scathing-attack-jolts-europe
    ▻https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2025/12/08/council-clinches-deal-on-eu-law-about-returns-of-illegally-staying-
    ▻https://euobserver.com/migration/aracb943dd
    ▻https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-trade-perks-migration-low-tariff-access
    ▻https://euobserver.com/EU%20&%20the%20World/ar9bbd9225
    ▻https://euobserver.com/Rule%20of%20Law/ar0c5403fa
    ▻https://www.euractiv.com/news/rapporteur-brunner-rules-out-eu-led-return-hubs
    ▻https://www.statewatch.org/analyses/2025/exporting-carceral-migration-management-30-million-from-the-eu-to-senega
    ▻https://euobserver.com/migration/arb0489de8
    ▻https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2025/11/19/un-agency-warns-afghanistan-unfit-for-returns-as-eu-attempts-to-deport-rej
    ▻https://euobserver.com/migration/ar2edba834
    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/68018/eu-parliament-greenlights-stronger-europol-powers-to-combat-smuggling-
    ▻https://www.statewatch.org/news/2025/november/european-parliament-development-committee-report-pushes-to-use-aid-as-mi
    ▻https://euromedrights.org/fr/actualites-de-lue-migrants-et-refugies-dans-la-region-euromed
    ▻https://www.senat.fr/fileadmin/Europe_et_international/Europe/Notes/EUR_2025_361_Note_actu_Pacte_MeditVF.pdf
    ▻https://www.statewatch.org/analyses/2021/eu-moves-ahead-with-plans-to-use-visa-policy-as-leverage-to-increase-dep

  • How much money do German states pay out to people they deport?

    Recent headlines in the German press have focused on money being paid to criminals being deported from Germany. Some of the thousands of people obliged to leave Germany do receive financial support when deported, but these payments differ depending on the state the person got deported from. InfoMigrants went to find out more.

    Almost 7,500 rejected asylum seekers and others obliged to leave Germany have been deported by plane to their home countries during the first six months of this year.

    As regional public broadcaster MDR reported last week, the 81 rejected asylum seekers on board the deportation flight from Leipzig to Kabul on July 18 — the first such flight in over a year — were serious and most serious criminal offenders.

    What’s more, they all received cash benefits as return support — but the sums varied depending on the state responsible for their deportation and their financial situation.

    For instance, Afghans for whom the southern state of Bavaria was responsible received no more than 100 euros, whereas four convicted criminals from Thuringia each reportedly received 1,000 euros.

    Since Germany’s 16 states are responsible for payments to deportees, InfoMigrants contacted the responsible ministries of seven of them — Bavaria, Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt, Baden-Württemberg, North Rhine-Wesphalia, Schleswig-Holstein and Rhineland-Palatinate — plus the federal Interior Ministry to get a clearer picture of the extent and policies towards cash payments for deported persons.

    Which criteria are used to determine the payments?

    When it comes to financial support for people obliged to leave Germany in the context of a deportation, no legal regulations govern the payments, a spokesperson for the Federal Interior Ministry told InfoMigrants.

    “Whether payments are made and, if so, how much, is decided at the discretion of the competent authorities in the federal states,” the spokesperson said, adding that this explains the different terms for and amounts of the payments.

    When it comes to the question of why the money was paid, all state ministries cited two reasons: securing deportees’ immediate travel and provision in the home country as well as making sure the deportation can go ahead. Courts in Germany can issue a deportation ban if it can be demonstrated that the deportee would be at risk of immediate impoverishment once they reached their destination.

    Migrants deported from the southern state of Baden-Württenberg need to “credibly demonstrate” that they lack sufficient financial means to reach their destination in their home country or that they cannot provide themselves with the necessary provisions until they arrive there.

    If that’s the case, an “appropriate amount of pocket money may be provided,” the ministry stated.

    A spokesperson for the responsible ministry in North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) echoed this statement, adding that the cash payments are first and foremost to ensure the deportation’s legality. Citing a ruling by Germany’s Federal Constitutional Court, the spokesperson noted that a deportation ban can be issued if the deportee is at risk of immediate impoverishment.

    The other ministries approached by InfoMigrants provided similar answers.
    Varying amounts

    When it comes to the monetary support for repatriated persons, the amount of cash distributed varies from state to state and from person to person.

    Answers from the seven states InfoMigrants surveyed ranged from as low as 50 euros up to 1,000 euros and more.

    Several states told us there were exceptions to their respective rules (see next chapter): In NRW, for example, more than 50 euros is paid in case they need more to reach their final destination after landing.

    The ministry further said that the payment is made by the foreigners’ office responsible for the deportation when the repatriation is carried out.

    While the baseline is 30 euros in Rhineland-Palatinate, up to 1,000 euros may be paid out “in cases of deportation of destitute persons in special circumstances.”

    The ministry in Rhineland-Palatinate told InfoMigrants that the federal government last year favored paying 1,000 euros to Afghans in the context of last year’s deportation flight to Afghanistan, the first one since the Taliban takeover in 2021.

    As part of the new government, in power since this May, the Federal Interior Ministry told InfoMigrants in a written statement that “unlike during the last legislature,” it has “expressly not issued any guidelines” on the amount (Handgeld) to be paid out.

    It furthermore stated that Bavaria and other states have paid between zero and 100 euros, depending on the deportee’s situation. “If some states have paid more, that was their own decision,” the ministry spokesperson said.

    The ministry in Rhineland-Palatinate further explained that the amount varied nonetheless depending on each deported person’s financial situation: While two of the six Afghans in last year’s sole deportation flight from Rhineland-Palatinate received the full 1,000 euro amount, three received money that brought what they already had up to the maximum 1,000, (it wasn’t specified how much that was for each individual), and one received nothing.

    How is return assistance calculated?

    The individual sum deportees receive depends on a number of factors. MDR reported that the basis is a means test, that is an assessment of the person’s assets. If the person has sufficient means, they won’t get anything.

    Average income and cost of living in the destination country, as well as the individual needs of deportees, such as illness or disability, are also part of the assessment basis, according to MDR. The individual needs are evaluated differently from state to state though.

    The 1,000 euros in return assistance is based on guidelines from the Federal Ministry of the Interior’s REAG/GARP program, according to German public broadcaster news show Tagesschau information.

    The aim of the assistance is reportedly to motivate asylum seekers who are obliged to leave the country to voluntarily return to their home country or a third country. In addition to money for the flight or bus ticket, a one-time subsidy of 1,000 euros per person is recommended, and 500 euros for minors.
    File photo used as illustration: The amount of money given to Afghan deportees has triggered a heated debate in Germany, especially as many of them are reported to have been convicted criminals | Photo: EHL Media/IMAGO

    According to MDR citing the Federal Interior Ministry, a total of 21.5 million euros was paid out in return assistance in 2023.

    According to the responsible ministry in Saxony, the return support is calculated on the basis of personal circumstances and the cost of living in the home country. The amount also often goes by court rulings about similar cases, the ministry added.

    In Saxony-Anhalt, the cash payments depend on the type of deportation (e.g. Dublin cases —where a person is being returned to another EU state, their first of entry in the bloc, where they have perhaps already applied for asylum), deportees’ age and how needy they are.

    Dublin cases, for instance, receive 30 euros, and solo travelers generally get 50 euros.
    Cash allowance versus ’subsistence income’

    Based on the answers we received, there are two different types of financial support for deportees: so-called Reisebeihilfen (travel aid) or Handgeld (literally hand money, i.e. cash allowance), and Existenzsicherungsmittel (subsistence income, i.e. financial means to secure your livelihood).

    All are paid in cash in euros, according to the ministries.

    The purpose of Handgeld is to ensure that deported persons can travel from the airport to their final destination, as well as make urgent purchases on their way there including food, water and a sim card.

    The amount of Handgeld is a voluntary payment and thus varies between 25 and 50 euros depending on the federal state, MDR reported. Most states contacted by InfoMigrants stated that adult migrants receive 50 euros, while children traveling with their family are entitled to 25 euros. In Saxony, children 12 years or younger could be paid 25 euros.

    Both the ministry in NRW and the Federal Interior Ministry noted that in addition to the cash allowance, some deportees might get extra reintegration support through the EU Reintegration Program, which offers individual assistance for returnees in their home countries — if they meet the requirements.

    Existenzsicherungsmittel, on the other hand, are non-legally binding repatriation grants to secure a minimum care for a certain period of time. According to MDR, this includes a ticket to reach returnees’ hometown, or money for medical supplies for the ill or disabled. This support, which is covered by the states, is only accessed if the deportee is out of money.

    In the case of Afghans, for example, the ministry in Rhineland-Palatinate told InfoMigrants that the 1,000 euros they receive is to guarantee their living expenses “for a transitional period above the poverty line”.

    It is however important to note that the terms and services used in deportations are not clearly distinguished by the authorities of the federal states.

    Moreover, five of the seven ministries that answered our questions either stated that the payments are not recorded statistically or didn’t comment on this particular issue.

    The only reliable figure provided is the 44,000 euros paid out in Handgeld to at least 1,010 persons last year in NRW.

    How many deportations from Germany have taken place this year?

    All ministries that replied to our request for comment provided current deportation figures.

    Some 2,500 persons including Dublin cases and close to 1,788 persons were deported from North Rhine-Westphalia and Bavaria — Germany’s two most populous states — as of June 3, respectively.

    In Saxony-Anhalt, which has one ninth of the population of NRW, 348 people were deported as of July 31. Saxony, Germany’s sixth-most populous state, deported 506 people as of June 30.

    The figures for Baden-Württemberg, Rhineland-Palatinate and Schleswig-Holstein were 2,210 as of late July, 591 and 436 (both as of late June) respectively.

    Across Germany, 6,000 people were deported in the first three months of this year, 28 percent more than during the same period last year.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/66197/how-much-money-do-german-states-pay-out-to-people-they-deport

    #Allemagne #migrations #renvois #expulsions #coût #migrations #réfugiés #aide_au_retour
    –—

    ajouté à la métaliste sur les coûts des renvois:
    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1140905

  • Germany’s interior minister proposes sharing deportations among EU states

    Interior Minister #Alexander_Dobrindt has proposed that Germany could carry out deportations to Afghanistan on behalf of other EU states, amid EU talks on a new Return Regulation requiring mutual recognition of deportation orders.

    German Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt has proposed that Germany could, in future, carry out deportations to Afghanistan on behalf of other EU states. “Conversely, perhaps other countries can take over repatriations where they have negotiated better agreements on returns,” he said after discussions with his European counterparts in Luxembourg.

    At the meeting, the ministers also discussed whether EU countries should be required to recognize deportation orders issued by other member states. The issue is part of the European Commission’s proposed Return Regulation, which seeks to replace the 2008 Return Directive and is considered particularly controversial among member states.

    According to the German government, countries affected by so-called secondary migration — the onward movement of asylum seekers from the EU country of first entry to “destination states” such as Germany — fear being left with the administrative burden, costs, and legal uncertainties of deportations.

    Dobrindt emphasized that simply recognizing a return order is not enough. “Of course, there can’t be a system in which some states merely recognize that deportations may occur, while others are compelled to carry them out," he said. As a possible reform, he proposed that member states could take over deportations for others, provided they hold corresponding agreements with third countries.

    The European Commission’s latest progress report on implementing the Pact on Migration and Asylum underlines that strengthening "return and readmission cooperation with third countries” is now a key external policy priority. The EU is expanding partnerships with governments in countries of origin and transit to facilitate deportations and reduce irregular arrivals. This focus echoes Dobrindt’s position that direct negotiations with regimes such as the Taliban are necessary to ensure the return of offenders, even when diplomatic relations remain limited.
    The EU Return Regulation

    According to the European Council on Refugees and Exiles (ECRE), the Commission’s March 2025 proposal for a Return Regulation introduces a European Return Order (ERO), under which EU states will be required to recognize and enforce each other’s deportation decisions by 2027. This system effectively allows one member state to carry out deportations on behalf of another, institutionalizing the kind of burden-sharing that Dobrindt recently suggested in relation to Afghanistan.

    The proposal also establishes a legal basis for “return hubs” in third countries, expands detention powers, and limits appeal rights — measures that critics and human rights groups warn will further erode human-rights safeguards.

    In a statement published by Amnesty International — joined by more than 200 organizations — the Commission’s Return Regulation is condemned as a shift toward a “Deportation Regulation” rooted in punitive enforcement rather than protection.

    The signatories warn that the draft enables deportations to third countries with which individuals have no prior connection, permits the establishment of “return hubs” outside EU territory, significantly expands detention powers to 24 months (including for children), weakens appeal rights, and intensifies surveillance and digital monitoring. They argue such measures violate international human rights norms, risk pushing people into legal limbo, and disproportionately affect racialized groups.
    The cost of deportations

    Beyond legal and moral debates, the cost of deportations remains a major concern across the EU.

    Deportations remain one of the EU’s most expensive migration measures. According to Germany’s Bundesrechnungshof, returning one person can cost between 5,000 and 15,000 euros, depending on destination and security needs. Flights to countries such as Afghanistan or Pakistan are among the costliest, often requiring chartered aircraft, medical staff, and police escorts.

    InfoMigrants recently reported that deportees also receive cash payments ranging from 50 to 1,000 euros, depending on the federal state and financial situation, with 21.5 million euros distributed nationwide in 2023 under the REAG/GARP return assistance program — primarily to ensure deportations comply with humanitarian and legal standards.

    Supporters of tighter coordination under the European Return Regulation argue that shared procedures and data could reduce duplication and costs. While critics counter that the administrative and humanitarian obligations make large-scale returns inherently costly. The Commission’s three billion euros “Solidarity Pool”, created to help member states implement the new Pact on Migration and Asylum, may temporarily offset these expenses — but the long-term financial sustainability of the EU’s return system remains uncertain.

    Plans for ’indefinite detention’

    Dobrindt has also announced plans for “indefinite detention” for those slated for deportation, drawing criticism from his coalition partners. His rhetoric reflects a hardening tone in Germany’s migration debate. In recent weeks, he has insisted that “our country must no longer be a magnet for illegal migration — we are changing migration policy,” adding that Germany is moving from being a “brake” to a “driver” in Europe’s migration turnaround. He has further stated: “We must end the overextension of our country.”

    The proposal triggered sharp criticism from coalition partners in the Social Democratic Party (SPD) and the Greens, who warned that indefinite detention would violate the German constitution and European human rights law. SPD migration expert Helge Lindh called the idea “a breach of fundamental rights,” while Green Party MP Filiz Polat described it as “legally and morally unacceptable.”

    Dobrindt’s stance also aligns with a wider shift toward restrictive rhetoric within the governing coalition, as the government faces public frustration over housing shortages, integration challenges, and local budget strains. The Interior Ministry recorded more than 220,000 asylum applications in the first half of 2025, a year-on-year increase of over 20 percent.

    While critics accuse Dobrindt of courting right-wing sentiment ahead of next year’s regional elections, supporters within the CSU say he is responding to “the mood of the country” and restoring public trust in migration control.

    German Talks with the Taliban Are Controversial

    Germany is moving toward formalizing deportations of Afghan nationals convicted of crimes, following direct negotiations between German officials and Taliban authorities in Kabul. According to the Interior Ministry, a delegation recently held “technical talks” with Taliban representatives — the most concrete engagement between Berlin and the Islamist regime since its takeover in 2021.

    In his Bundestag speech on September 18, 2025, Dobrindt confirmed that Germany intends to continue deportations to Afghanistan: "We will ensure that these flights continuously, regularly, and properly return criminals to Afghanistan.”

    According to reports, the talks are close to producing a formal deportation agreement. The move is highly controversial, as Germany maintains no official diplomatic relations with the Taliban, whose rule has been marked by systematic violations of human and women’s rights. Critics warn that such cooperation risks legitimizing the regime and undermining international isolation efforts. Supporters, however, argue that limited engagement could allow Berlin to press for human rights guarantees and manage deportations without relying on intermediaries such as Qatar.

    Since the Taliban’s return to power, Germany has conducted two deportation flights to Afghanistan, both facilitated by Qatar, including one in July 2025 carrying 81 men convicted of serious crimes.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/67524/germanys-interior-minister-proposes-sharing-deportations-among-eu-stat
    #expulsions_communes #expulsions_conjointes #migrations #réfugiés #renvois #expulsions #Afghanistan #réfugiés_afghans #Allemagne #directive_retour #mouvements_secondaires #accords_de_réadmission #European_Return_Order (#ERO) #return_hubs #coût #European_Return_Regulation #détention_administrative #rétention #détention_illimitée #talibans

    ping @karine4

    –—

    ajouté à la métaliste sur les coûts des renvois :
    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1140905

    • L’Allemagne se propose d’expulser les Afghans pour le compte d’autres pays européens

      L’Allemagne est favorable à ce principe de répartition des expulsions en fonction des accords d’expulsions conclus par les Etats membres de l’UE avec des pays tiers.

      D’après Alexander Dobrindt, le ministre allemand de l’Intérieur issu du parti conservateur CSU, l’Allemagne pourrait à l’avenir se charger des expulsions de ressortissants afghans pour le compte d’autres pays de l’Union européenne (UE). « À l’inverse, d’autres pays pourraient peut-être prendre en charge les rapatriements lorsqu’ils ont négocié de meilleurs accords en matière de retour », a-t-il déclaré après de récentes discussions avec ses homologues européens à Luxembourg.

      La question de savoir si un pays de l’UE a le devoir de reconnaître les décisions d’expulsion prises par d’autres États membres a également été débattue lors de cette réunion.

      Cette reconnaissance mutuelle fait partie des nouvelles règles en matière de retours proposées par la Commission européenne. Particulièrement controversé, ce plan vise à remplacer la directive retour de 2008.

      Selon Berlin, les pays touchés par la migration secondaire, c’est-à-dire par le déplacement des demandeurs d’asile depuis le pays par lequel ils sont entrés dans l’UE vers des pays de destination comme l’Allemagne, craignent l’ampleur de la charge administrative, des coûts et des incertitudes juridiques liés aux expulsions.

      Pour Alexander Dobrindt « il ne peut évidemment pas exister de système dans lequel certains États se contentent de reconnaître que des expulsions peuvent avoir lieu, tandis que d’autres sont contraints de les mettre en œuvre ». La réforme proposée envisage donc la possibilité pour des États de prendre en charge les expulsions à la place d’autres, à condition qu’ils aient conclu des accords avec des pays tiers.

      Le dernier rapport d’étape de la Commission européenne sur la mise en œuvre du Pacte sur la migration et l’asile souligne que le renforcement de la « coopération avec les pays tiers en matière de retour et de réadmission » est désormais une priorité clé de la politique extérieure européenne.

      L’UE cherche ainsi à élargir ses partenariats avec les gouvernements des pays d’origine et de transit afin de faciliter les expulsions et de réduire les arrivées irrégulières.

      Cette orientation fait écho à la position d’Alexander Dobrindt, selon laquelle des négociations directes avec des régimes comme celui des talibans en Afghanistan sont nécessaires pour garantir le retour des personnes condamnées par la justice, même lorsque les relations diplomatiques sont limitées.
      Le règlement européen sur le retour

      Selon le Conseil européen sur les réfugiés et les exilés (ECRE), la proposition de règlement sur le retour présentée par la Commission en mars dernier introduit une décision européenne en vertu de laquelle les États membres de l’UE seront tenus de reconnaître et d’exécuter les décisions d’expulsion des autres Etats d’ici 2027.

      Ce système permet en effet à un pays d’effectuer des expulsions pour le compte d’un autre, institutionnalisant ainsi la suggestion d’Alexander Dobrindt pour le cas de l’Afghanistan.

      La proposition est dénoncée par les ONG de défense des droits de l’homme.

      D’autant qu’elle établit également une base juridique pour la création de « centres de retour » dans des pays tiers, élargit les pouvoirs de Etats en matière de détention et limite les droits de recours.

      Dans une déclaration publiée par Amnesty International et signée par plus de 200 organisations, l’approche de Bruxelles n’est pas un règlement sur le retour mais un « règlement sur l’expulsion », fondé sur une démarche punitive plutôt que sur la protection.

      Les signataires avertissent que le projet permet des expulsions vers des pays tiers avec lesquels les personnes concernées n’ont aucun lien, autorise la création de « centres de retour » en dehors du territoire de l’UE, étend considérablement les pouvoirs de détention à 24 mois (y compris pour les enfants), affaiblit les droits de recours et intensifie la surveillance et le contrôle numérique. Ils affirment que ces mesures violent les normes internationales en matière de droits humains, risquent de plonger les personnes concernées dans un vide juridique et affectent de manière disproportionnée certains groupes ethniques.
      Le coût des expulsions

      Au-delà des débats juridiques et moraux, les expulsions restent l’une des mesures migratoires les plus coûteuses pour les pays de l’UE.

      Selon la Cour des comptes allemande (Bundesrechnungshof), l’expulsion d’une personne peut coûter entre 5 000 et 15 000 euros, selon la destination et les besoins en matière de sécurité. Les vols vers des pays comme l’Afghanistan ou le Pakistan sont parmi les plus chers, nécessitant souvent des avions affrétés, du personnel médical et des escortes policières.

      De plus, les paiements en espèce versés aux personnes expulsées, qui peuvent varier entre 50 et 1000 euros, ont représenté quelque 21,5 millions d’euros en Allemagne en 2023 dans le cadre du programme d’aide au retour REAG/GARP, essentiellement pour garantir les normes humanitaires et juridiques des renvois.

      Les partisans d’un nouveau règlement sur le retour estiment que la mutualisation des procédures et des données pourrait réduire les doublons et les coûts.

      En face, ses détracteurs affirment que les obligations administratives et humanitaires rendent les retours à grande échelle trop coûteux. Le fonds de solidarité de trois milliards d’euros créé par la Commission pour aider les États membres à mettre en œuvre le nouveau Pacte sur la migration pourrait temporairement compenser ces dépenses, mais la viabilité financière à long terme du système de retour de l’UE reste incertaine.
      Projets de « détention illimitée »

      Alexander Dobrindt a également annoncé sa volonté de permettre des « détentions illimitées » pour les personnes devant être expulsées, provoquant une salve des critiques au sein de la coalition gouvernementale réunissant son camp des conservateurs et les sociaux-démocrates.

      Son discours reflète l’hostilité à l’immigration croissance en Allemagne. Ces dernières semaines, le ministre a rappelé que l’Allemagne « ne doit plus être un aimant pour l’immigration clandestine – nous changeons notre politique migratoire », ajoutant que le pays passait du rôle de « frein » à celui de « moteur » dans le changement de cap européen en matière de migration. « Nous devons mettre fin à la surexploitation de notre pays », a surenchéri Alexander Dobrindt.

      Le gouvernement allemand est confronté à la frustration de la population face à la pénurie de logements, aux défis de l’intégration et aux contraintes budgétaires locales. Le ministère de l’Intérieur a enregistré plus de 220 000 demandes d’asile au cours du premier semestre 2025, soit une augmentation de plus de 20 % par rapport à l’année précédente.

      Reste que selon le parti social-démocrate (SPD) et les Verts, la détention illimitée violerait la Constitution allemande et la législation européenne en matière de droits de l’Homme. Helge Lindh, expert en migration du SPD, a qualifié cette idée de « violation des droits fondamentaux », tandis que Filiz Polat, députée du Parti vert, l’a décrite comme « juridiquement et moralement inacceptable ».

      Alexander Dobrindt est ainsi accusé de courtiser les électeurs d’extrême-droite à l’approche des élections régionales de l’année prochaine.

      Dans le même temps, ses partisans affirment qu’il répond à « l’état d’esprit du pays » et rétablit la confiance du public dans le contrôle migratoire.
      Les négociations entre l’Allemagne et les talibans font polémique

      L’Allemagne a mené des négociations directes avec les talibans à Kaboul. Selon le ministère de l’Intérieur, une délégation allemande a récemment tenu des « discussions techniques » avec des représentants talibans, ce qui constitue l’engagement le plus concret entre Berlin et le régime fondamentaliste islamiste depuis sa prise de pouvoir en 2021.

      Dans son discours au Parlement le 18 septembre 2025, Alexander Dobrindt a confirmé que l’Allemagne avait l’intention de poursuivre les expulsions vers l’Afghanistan : « Nous veillerons à ce que ces vols ramènent de manière continue, régulière et appropriée les criminels en Afghanistan ».

      Selon certaines informations, les négociations seraient sur le point d’aboutir à un accord officiel d’expulsion.

      Cette décision est d’autant plus controversée que l’Allemagne n’entretient aucune relation diplomatique officielle avec Kaboul, dont le nouveau régime viole systématiquement les droits humains et les droits des femmes.

      Les détracteurs de cette coopération craignent qu’elle légitime le régime taliban et compromette les efforts internationaux qui visent à l’isoler pour faire pression. Ses partisans affirment qu’un engagement limité permettrait à Berlin d’exiger des garanties en matière de droits humains et de gérer les expulsions sans avoir recours à des intermédiaires tels que le Qatar.

      Depuis le retour au pouvoir des talibans, l’Allemagne a effectué deux vols d’expulsion vers l’Afghanistan, tous deux facilités par le Qatar, dont un en juillet 2025 transportant 81 hommes condamnés pour des crimes graves.

      ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/fr/post/67665/lallemagne-se-propose-dexpulser-les-afghans-pour-le-compte-dautres-pay

  • From borders to workplaces: How Europe is reinventing immigration control

    European governments are shifting from border enforcement to workplace restrictions. New research shows Austria, Germany, Ireland, and the UK now use job tests, wage thresholds, and employer lock-ins to limit migrant competition.

    When immigration makes the news in Europe, the focus is usually on borders. In the UK, headlines dwell on “small boats,” while across the EU, the debate often centers on asylum seekers crossing frontiers. Yet a quieter change has been unfolding — not at the border, but in the workplace.

    A recent study published by the London School of Economics titled The return of the state: how European governments regulate labour market competition from migrant workers shows how Austria, Germany, Ireland, and the United Kingdom have steadily tightened the rules that govern how migrants present in the country access jobs. Instead of relying only on border control, governments are introducing restrictions that decide who can be hired, on what terms, and at what pay.

    What restrictions look like

    The study identifies three main types of barriers that now shape the employment of migrants after they have entered the country:

    – Job vacancy tests — employers must first prove that no local worker is available before hiring someone from abroad.
    – Pay and qualification thresholds — migrants are often required to meet higher-than-average wages or education levels to ensure they do not undercut local labor.
    – Employer lock-in periods — many new arrivals are tied to one employer for at least a year before they can switch jobs.

    Asylum seekers face additional rules, such as waiting months before being permitted to work.

    Four countries, four paths — but converging outcomes

    Despite their different histories, the four countries studied ended up with strikingly similar systems.

    - Austria launched the Red-White-Red Card in 2004, combining vacancy checks with salary thresholds and binding skilled workers to one employer for at least a year.
    - Germany replaced its Aliens Law with a new residency framework in 2005 and later introduced the EU Blue Card, imposing wage floors and job tests, with skilled workers locked into their first employer for two years.

    - Ireland, once a country of emigration, imposed some of the strictest conditions: eight weeks of job advertising before a migrant can be hired, steep salary thresholds of 32,000-64,000 euros, and one-year employer ties.
    - The United Kingdom introduced a points-based visa system in 2008. Employers provided only statements that no locals were available, but workers remained tied to their sponsors. Salary thresholds applied, and the highly skilled Tier 1 visa was closed in 2011.

    By 2020, Austria and Ireland — which had few restrictions in the 1990s — had caught up with Germany and the UK. Even highly skilled workers, once thought to be exempt, were now subject to vacancy tests and salary floors.

    Beyond economic models and EU rules

    These changes challenge two common explanations.

    One argument, rooted in the “Varieties of Capitalism” framework, suggested liberal market economies like the UK and Ireland would stay more open, while coordinated economies like Austria and Germany would be more protective. In reality, all four converged on the same restrictive path.

    Another view is that the European Union drives migration policy. While Brussels has set minimum standards — such as waiting times for asylum seekers — most workplace restrictions were designed and enforced nationally.

    Instead, domestic politics mattered most. The EU’s enlargement in 2004 and 2007 sparked concern about job competition. In response, governments introduced stricter rules on access to employment, particularly in lower-skilled sectors.

    Attracting skilled labor from abroad

    While tightening access to jobs for migrants inside the country, European governments are, however, also launching schemes to draw in top talent.

    In the United Kingdom, the number of authorized sponsors for the skilled worker visa reached 110,500 in 2024 — reflecting continued demand — while the government is drafting reforms to attract high-ability professionals in artificial intelligence, life sciences, clean energy, and biosciences, as outlined in its upcoming immigration white paper.

    Germany has launched the new Opportunity Card, a points-based scheme that allows people to come and look for jobs in shortage sectors, with particular outreach to workers from India and African countries such as Kenya.

    Ireland continues to issue employment permits targeted at critical skills in areas such as IT and finance, while Austria promotes its Red-White-Red Card, a points-based system that gives preference to highly qualified migrants in shortage professions.
    The wider European tension

    The national policies examined by the LSE study mirror a broader contradiction across Europe: economies face growing labor shortages, but political debates continue to cast immigration as a problem to be “solved.”

    Last week the European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde noted that foreign-born workers make up only nine percent of the EU workforce but have accounted for half of all job growth since 2022. From hospitals to building sites, many industries depend on them.

    Yet anti-immigrant parties and populist rhetoric have raised the political stakes. In Germany, officials warn of looming labor shortages while asylum seekers face new restrictions. In the UK, the Labour government has pledged tougher visa salary rules despite warnings from employers that cuts in foreign recruitment will cripple care, construction, and hospitality.

    Governments often reach for workplace restrictions because they are politically useful. They are less visible than border fences, but they allow leaders to claim they are protecting local workers while still supplying some labor to employers.

    Economic consequences of protectionism

    The study cautions that this approach carries significant economic risks. By limiting migrant access to jobs, governments risk worsening shortages in care work, construction, agriculture, and other key industries.

    Strict wage thresholds and job tests also reduce flexibility, the study points out. Workers cannot easily move into roles where demand is greatest, slowing economic responsiveness. Over time, these barriers threaten growth, undermine competitiveness, and intensify the problems of aging populations.

    Employers may benefit in the short term when migrants are tied to contracts, but the wider economy loses out on the mobility and dynamism that come with a flexible labor force.

    From borders to labor markets

    The study concludes that Europe has shifted from controlling migration mainly at the border to managing it inside the labor market. This represents a new kind of protectionism: instead of shutting the door, states regulate the terms of entry into jobs.

    Politically, these measures are attractive because they offer an “easy win.” Governments can say they are shielding local workers without sparking business opposition. Employers often tolerate the extra bureaucracy, and some even welcome the stability of tied contracts. But migrants face reduced rights, limited freedom, and weaker bargaining power.

    The bigger lesson is that far from losing control to global markets or EU institutions, national governments remain firmly in charge. They are actively reshaping migration to balance economic needs, political pressures, and worker protection.

    Ever changing rules

    Europe’s migration debate is no longer just about who crosses its borders. Increasingly, it is about what kind of work migrants are allowed to do once they arrive, and under what terms.

    The shared path taken by Austria, Germany, Ireland, and the UK underscores this shift. States are using employment rules to manage migration in ways that are less visible but just as powerful as border controls. Europe may still look like a fortress, but it is one with many gates — and the rules governing those gates are being quietly rewritten.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/66644/from-borders-to-workplaces-how-europe-is-reinventing-immigration-contr

    #mobile_borders #hostile_environment #environnement_hostile #travail #migrations #contrôles_migratoires #frontières #lieu_de_travail #Allemagne #Autriche #marché_du_travail #restrictions #asile #demandeurs_d'asile #préférence_nationale #Rot-Weiß-Rot_Karte #Rot-Weiss-Rot_Karte #main_d'oeuvre #discours #rhétorique #statistiques #chiffres #protectionnisme #risque_économique #salaires

    ping @reka @karine4 @_kg_

    • The return of the state: how European governments regulate labour market competition from migrant workers

      What is the role of the market economy and of the European Union in shaping policies that limit migrants’ access to the labour market? While much of the existing research has examined the development of border policies in Europe, less attention has been given to post-entry measures regulating the employment of Third Country Nationals. We examine the role of different market economies and the European Union in devising lesser-known measures that target migrant labour market competition. Focusing on the period from 1990 to 2020, we analyse four case studies: Austria, Germany, Ireland, and the United Kingdom. We hypothesize that these migrant labour market competition measures (MCM) have emerged in ways that challenge both the marketization of migration thesis and predictions from theories of EU immigration policymaking and varieties of capitalism (VoC). While the European Union’s influence partially explains the adoption of some selective policies, the emergence of MCM transcends the VoC framework. Furthermore, contrary to marketization claims, states have sought to address labour market concerns about competition from migrants by adopting selective, rather than indiscriminate, regulatory approaches. We argue that the interplay between selectivity and measures restricting migrant labour market competition has become central to understanding how states regulate migration in the European Union.

      ▻https://comparativemigrationstudies.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40878-025-00433-3#Sec4

  • Has Italy’s Albania migrant deal completely failed ?

    One year after Albania’s parliament ratified the country’s migration centers deal with Italy, the two migrant holding centers constructed in Shengjin and Gjader stand completely empty. What happens next?

    Everything has returned to normal in the village of Gjader and the port town of Shengjin in northwestern Albania.

    Almost exactly a year to the day when the parliament ratified the country’s migrant center agreement with Italy, not a single migrant is in either of the facilities constructed in Gjader and Shengjin.

    The agreement signed by Italy and Albania in November 2023 and ratified by the Albanian parliament on February 22, 2024, envisioned that Italy would build migrant holding centers in Albania that would house up to 36,000 irregular migrants a year while their asylum applications are processed by Italy.
    Series of setbacks for the Italian government

    Since then, over 70 migrants — mainly from Africa and South Asia — have been transferred to Albania in three different groups.

    The first ship, which had 16 migrants on board, was sent to Albania on October 16. All of them were sent back to Italy after a court in Rome ruled that the transfer was unlawful and that repatriating them to their countries of origin could breach international legal protections.

    Two more migrant transfers followed: One group of eight was sent to Albania on November 8 and another group of 49 on January 28.

    In both cases, the Rome Court of Appeal ruled that the migrants could not be held in Albania until the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg has ruled on whether the asylum seekers’ countries of origin are considered safe for repatriation.

    The European Court of Justice is expected to rule on the matter on February 25.
    Monitors have left Albania

    Meanwhile, both Italian officials and NGO experts monitoring the situation in Albania have already left the country “until further notice.”

    Francesco Ferri, a migration expert at ActionAid, has been part of a delegation monitoring conditions in the Albanian centers since they were set up.

    “The delegation from Tavolo Asilo e Immigrazione [a national alliance of NGOs and civil society organizations that seeks to protect migrants’ rights in Italy] has conducted monitoring missions in Albania to observe the facilities set up and the context in which they operate,” he told DW. “We are currently no longer in Albania, but we continue to monitor the situation closely from a distance and are ready to return for further observation activities.”
    ’Scared, bewildered and disoriented’ migrants

    All 73 migrants transferred to Albania had tried to reach Italy or Malta by boat from Libya and were, according to Ferri, “seriously afraid of being sent back to their countries of origin.”

    “We met individuals who were scared, bewildered and disoriented,” he said. “They had no awareness of the procedures, were not adequately prepared to apply for asylum, and were in conditions of isolation. Their situation clearly demonstrates how the Albania model entails a systemic violation of rights.”

    According to the website Infomigrants, the Italian government is now considering plans to repurpose the centers. One option believed to be on the table is the transformation of the centers into “repatriation facilities.” However, it seems likely that this plan, too, would face opposition.

    Ferri is strictly opposed to such an alternative use. “It must be entirely rejected,” he said, “as it would lead to further severe human rights violations. The risk of stabilizing and expanding these structures remains real, especially if the outsourcing model were to be replicated elsewhere. The analysis of its outcomes so far indicates that the definitive closure of these centers is the only alternative.”
    ’A clamorous failure’

    Despite the attempts of both governments to make the agreement work, many experts and opposition parties in Italy have been against it from the word go. They consider the project an abuse of human rights and — at an estimated total cost of €1 billion ($1.04 billion) — a waste of money, too.

    Elly Schlein, the leader of Italy’s center-left Democratic Party, has described the agreement as “a clamorous failure,” called on Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni to resign, and said that the migrant center model in Albania will never work.

    Ferri agrees. “Very few people have been transferred, and all of them were subsequently returned to Italy,” he says. “The centers remained empty for most of the year and, during operational periods, hosted only a very limited number of individuals. Organizational difficulties, legal challenges and the political context have hindered its [the agreement’s] implementation.”
    Meloni determined to make the agreement work

    DW contacted the Italian government, asking it for its assessment of the success of the agreement and whether it intends to repurpose the centers. No response had been received by the time of publication.

    However, speaking at an event with senior police officers just a few days ago, Meloni said that her government was determined to continue with the Italy-Albania agreement.

    “We are committed to finding a solution to every obstacle,” she said, adding that “Italian citizens are asking their government to stop illegal migration because it causes insecurity.”

    The agreement has been the subject of debate between the Albanian government and the opposition right from the start. Indeed, the opposition Democratic Party of Albania has vowed that should it win the parliamentary election on May 11, “the contract with Italy will not be renewed.”
    A test case for Europe

    Earlier this week, European Commissioner for Internal Affairs and Migration Magnus Brunner met with Giorgia Meloni and discussed “the possible early adoption of the new concept of a safe country of origin.”

    Before traveling to Italy, Brunner told the Italian media that the legislative package on migrant repatriations being examined by the European Commission would be “very ambitious” and would include “clear obligations on repatriations,” "strict rules for those representing a threat to security" and a “more coordinated” framework at European level.

    Francesco Ferri is still very concerned.

    “The risk remains that European governments will continue to explore outsourcing solutions, thereby reducing protections for asylum seekers and shifting the responsibility for international protection beyond the borders of the EU,” he said.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/63018/has-italys-albania-migrant-deal-completely-failed

    #Albanie #externalisation #migrations #réfugiés #Italie #échec

    –-

    ajouté à la métaliste sur l’#accord entre #Italie et #Albanie pour la construction de #centres d’accueil (sic) et identification des migrants/#réfugiés sur le territoire albanais...

    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1043873

  • Message de Nihad Suljić sur FB (26.02.2025) :

    Na spomeniku podignutom u znak na sjećanje na izbjeglice koje su poginule dok su pokušavale ući u Italiju napravili smo malu ispravku.

    Naime isklesano je da je to krivica krijumčara, pa smo ih podsjetili da je isključivi krivac zato evropska unija i njena politika zatvorenih granica.

    Olovkom i svojom rukom.

    Nema na čemu. 😊

    Traduction rapide et automatique :

    Nous avons fait une petite correction sur le monument érigé en mémoire des réfugiés morts en essayant d’entrer en Italie.
    En l’occurrence, il a été sculpté que c’était la faute des passeurs, nous leur avons donc rappelé que l’Union européenne et sa politique frontalière fermée en étaient les seuls coupables.
    Avec un crayon et ma propre main.
    De rien. 😊

    #monument #mémoriel #naufrage #mourir_en_mer #morts_en_mer #responsabilité #trafic_d'êtres_humains #trafiquants #scafisti #passeurs #Italie #Cutro #résistance

    ping @reka

    • Italy: #Crotone remembers victims two years after deadly migrant shipwreck

      On the eve of the second anniversary of the Cutro shipwreck, the city of Crotone organized a commemoration ceremony to honor the 94 victims, including 35 children and teenagers, on February 26.

      Two years have passed since the shipwreck off Steccato di Cutro, but the city of Crotone, in Italy’s southern region of Calabria, has not forgotten. The community continues to honor the 94 victims of the tragedy, including 35 minors, as well as the tears of the survivors and the pain of their families.

      These feelings were visible at a commemoration ceremony held on February 25 on the eve of the anniversary, at the "Garden of Alì — a memorial space established by the local municipality in honor of the youngest victim of the shipwreck. Buried in the local cemetery, Alì has become a symbolic son of the entire Crotone community.

      To mark the occasion, 94 trees were planted in the garden to remember the adults, along with 35 bushes to commemorate the children who lost their lives at sea.

      ’Crotone doesn’t forget, will never forget’ — mayor

      After a minute of silence, which Crotone Mayor Vincenzo Voce ordered all schools in the city to observe, the choir Anna Frank directed by professor Luisa Floccari performed at the ceremony. The event was attended by local authorities and members of the military, as well as by students and representatives of volunteer groups, together with several residents.

      “Today we remember 94 innocent victims”, said Mayor Voce.

      “And in commemorating them I want to state once again that humanity must not have any political color, because it is a feeling that belongs to our people. The residents of Crotone proved it during those terrible days, when institutions, security forces, doctors, volunteers, social workers and journalists were united in this very strong and fundamental principle. Crotone does not and will not forget,” he added.

      Bouquet of flowers laid at the foot of installation dedicated to victims

      The sense of solidarity shown by Crotone’s residents was also emphasized by Sergio Ferrari, president of the Province of Crotone, who stated, “nobody during those days pulled back or looked the other way. The population of Crotone set a great example for Italy and the world”, he said.

      The prefect of Crotone, Franca Ferraro, addressed young people at the ceremony, urging them to “visit Alì’s garden and, in particular, remember what happened.”

      At the end of the ceremony, the prefect and mayor laid a bouquet of flowers in the city’s colors at the foot of the installation remembering Alì and the other victims of the shipwreck.

      ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/63102/italy-crotone-remembers-victims-two-years-after-deadly-migrant-shipwre

    • Cutro, imbrattata la stele in ricordo della strage

      Cancellata la scritta sui trafficanti di esseri umani, con un riferimento critico alle politiche dell’Unione Europea sull’immigrazione

      Con un pennerello nero è stata imbrattata a Cutro la stele in ricordo delle vittime del naufragio. Dal messaggio che porta la firma del Consiglio comunale, è stato cancellato il riferimento a “trafficanti e scafisti di esseri umani”, sostituito con la parola “Unione Europea”.

      ▻https://www.rainews.it/tgr/calabria/video/2025/02/cutro-stele--6d20822c-5f6c-4747-97ab-b1ba97c4450b.html

  • Italy: Migrants responsible for at least one third of food grown in #Puglia

    Migrant workers are responsible for producing at least one third of the food produced in the southern Puglia region of Italy, said Italian farmers’ association Coldiretti recently.

    In the Puglia region of southern Italy, “almost a third of Made in Italy food products are produced by foreign workers, with 22,314 workers from around the world working regularly in agriculture, equal to 10 percent of all non-EU agricultural workers in the country,” the Puglia branch of the Italian farmers association Coldiretti Puglia said in a February 11 statement.

    It went on to underscore that, “foreign workers are highly represented in the agricultural sector,” and that, “despite the gradual drop over the past five years, they remain essential in Puglia for tree crops, where they account for 53.8 percent (fruit and viticulture), and 17.7 percent in horticulture (strawberries, melons, salads, tomatoes, and radicchio).”

    Red tape means workers ’arrive when harvest is over’

    “Almost 88 percent of non-EU farmhands are employed on a seasonal basis and account for 10 percent of contracted workers regularly employed in agriculture,” the statement noted.

    “These are workers that often have for years been collaborating with Italian agricultural firms and who every year cross the border to return to their home countries,” it added.

    “This is a need that has become more pressing due to the lack of Italian manpower and depends on the calendar for harvests.” This “significant presence” of foreign workers “is not however enough to meet the needs of agricultural firms, especially due to some gaps in the current regulations, starting from the click day mechanism [on which applications can be made online to get entrance visas to Italy, Ed.], with small quotas that are not updated in relation to the seasonal needs of the agricultural sector.”

    Coldiretti Puglia went on to point out: “It often happens, in fact, that workers arrive when the harvesting for which they had been requested has already ended.”

    ’Direct management for migration needed’

    The quotas set aside for the agricultural sector are significant, and in Italy’s agricultural sector about 35 percent of the workers are immigrants.

    “To overcome the current difficulties, it is important to shift to a direct, controlled management of migration flows,” believes the association.

    “The latest modifications of regulations on the immigration decree are an important step towards simplification and respect for the timeline of workers’ entrance [into the country], which should be implemented with greater involvement of employer associations and consulates. In this way, it would also be easier to discover any instances of labor exploitation,” #Coldiretti Puglia concluded.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/62887/italy-migrants-responsible-for-at-least-one-third-of-food-grown-in-pug

    #agriculture #Pouilles #agriculture #migrations #travailleurs_étrangers

  • Germany wants asylum seekers already recognized in Greece to consider return

    The German government is seeking strategies to get asylum seekers in the country, who have already been recognized as refugees in Greece, to return there. This applies to a small group of people, who have been allowed to lodge asylum claims in Germany as a second EU country after Greece.

    A spokesperson for the Federal Ministry of the Interior said that the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF) has started to send out information letters to individuals who have already been granted protection status in Greece and who are either pursuing another asylum process in Germany or whose application in Germany has been declared inadmissible.

    These letters are intended to inform these individuals about the possibility of a voluntary return to Greece and the support services that would immediately be available for them there.

    Among other things, the letters tell those they are addressed to that in the first few months upon their return, already recognized refugees in Greece would receive accommodation, food and social counseling, where applicable.

    Furthermore, integration programs are also being rolled out to facilitate the integration of returning refugees, the interior ministry spokesperson said — including language classes and support in finding a job.

    The move to incentivize certain asylum seekers to return to Greece comes amid calls to limit migration to Germany ahead of general elections.

    A unique exception

    The predicament of asylum seekers who already have been given protection status in Greece but have come to Germany subsequently to lodge another application there is a somewhat unique situation in Germany’s current asylum system.

    It comes after six months ago, an Administrative Court in the western city of Gelsenkirchen had ruled that despite asylum seekers ordinarily only being allowed to apply for asylum in one country in the European Union under the so-called Dublin Regulation, the living conditions in Greece were “unacceptable for refugees,” allowing them to also lodge a secondary claim in Germany.

    That court ruling said that in view of “considerable bureaucratic hurdles and lack of state support, it can still be assumed in principle that those entitled to protection in Greece are very unlikely to be able to find secure accommodation and secure their livelihood through legal employment or state support” there.

    In other words, the court ruling mostly relied on the fact that a return to a normal, productive life for people escaping violence and war was regarded as difficult under the current situation in Greece.

    In the first ten months of 2024, at least 21,110 people applied for asylum in Germany after already being granted protection status in Greece, according to numbers cited by the DPA news agency.

    Uptick in Greek economy

    However, the German government is now encouraging those who already have protection in Greece to return, especially taking into consideration that the country’s economy has been improving.

    Although Greece’s unemployment rate remains relatively high in comparison to other EU nations, it recently dipped under the ten-percent mark, which is significantly lower than what it was three years ago.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/62755/germany-wants-asylum-seekers-already-recognized-in-greece-to-consider-
    #Allemagne #renvois #retours #Grèce #migrations #réfugiés #asile

  • German state plans to intensify confiscation of valuables from asylum seekers

    A proposal by the Ministry of Justice of Germany’s southern federal state of Baden-Württemberg suggests new restrictions and regulations to be introduced when it comes to taking in asylum seekers.

    According to local newspaper reports from the Stuttgarter Zeitung and Stuttgarter Nachrichten, the proposed measures include expanding the confiscation of jewelry, cash and valuables from asylum seekers arriving without identification documents.

    State Secretary of Justice Siegfried Lorek of the Christian Democrats said that it was important to “clearly communicate that we will confiscate money and valuables within the legal framework” as a deterrent for people with fraudulent or weak cases. Asylum seekers would be allowed to keep 200 euros, with any additional funds used to cover procedural costs.

    To date, this practice has only been applied in isolated cases, he added, stressing that in the future it would be applied across the board.

    “If word gets around, this will reduce the number of arrivals,” he told reporters.

    Following the Danish example

    Taking valuables from asylum seekers on arrival to fund part of the costs of housing them is already practiced in Denmark, which as part of a wider set of asylum reforms has led to a sharp drop in asylum seekers coming to the Scandinavian nation.

    Any item valued at more than 1,300 euros — including jewelry, watches and even wedding rings — can be taken away under the Danish law.

    Lorek said that the same was also legal to be applied in Germany at the state level, adding however that further measures of a similar nature would have to be decided by the federal government.

    Only one appeal

    State Justice Minister Marion Gentges, also a member of the Christian Democrats party (CDU), meanwhile has come out in favor of a similar redesign of the German asylum system after the Danish model.

    She told the local papers that she would like to examine whether the legal recourse that asylum seekers are entitled to in the event of a rejected asylum decision could be shortened. In Denmark, she said, failed asylum seekers only had one appeal available in such cases.

    “We need rule of law and are committed to it, but we don’t need an overflowing legal system,” Gentges told the two newspapers.

    Cash incentives to leave

    Gentges also said she would possibly entertain the idea of offering cash incentives for rejected asylum seekers if they left the country voluntarily.

    Denmark currently offers up to 3,500 euros per person, however, only if an appeal against a rejection is not lodged.

    A few months ago, Danish Migration and Integration Minister Kaare Dybvad Bek already suggested that other European nations — including Germany — should copy his country’s approach to handling migration.

    However, Germany cannot copy all alternative ideas to deal with immigration issues from Denmark: Although Denmark is a member of the European Union, it is not subject to European Law in many instances after being granted an opt-out clause from shared EU laws in 1990.

    Criticism against initiative

    The Refugee Council in Baden-Württemberg meanwhile has criticized the justice ministry’s plans.

    The public body stressed that many refugees did not have any significant funds or belongings that could be confiscated anyway.

    “The latest proposals from the Ministry of Justice are another example of how harshness is to be demonstrated in the current context of migration policy — relatively detached from the factual framework conditions,” says Refugee Council Director Anja Bartel.

    “(I)t is also clear that anyone applying for asylum is exercising a fundamental right and this must not be associated with costs,” says Bartel.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/62785/german-state-plans-to-intensify-confiscation-of-valuables-from-asylum-
    #Allemagne #migrations #réfugiés #confiscation #confiscation_de_biens #bijoux #aide_au_retour #asile #recours #droit_d'asile #argent

    –-

    pour rappel, au #Danemark en 2016 (pratique qui était déjà courante en Suisse)...

    La révision de la loi sur l’asile au Danemark a secoué la presse internationale en janvier. Elle a également été dénoncée par les organismes onusiens et européens. L’attention médiatique a surtout porté sur la saisie de tous les biens « patrimoniaux » des demandeurs d’asile : les requérants se voient dépouillés de toute liquidité à concurrence de 1350 francs et de tout bien personnel à montant équivalent.

    ▻https://seenthis.net/messages/459127

  • Nuovo decreto Albania, l’accordo sarà modificato : il piano del governo italiano per la competenza a Tirana

    L’esecutivo vuole evitare nuovi stop da parte della magistratura: l’ipotesi di un decreto. L’opposizione: una follia, si fermino

    Ripristinare subito l’operatività dei centri albanesi di Gjader e Shengjin, a prescindere dalla decisione della Corte di giustizia europea prevista per il prossimo 25 febbraio. Anche a costo, come soluzione estrema, di togliere la giurisdizione italiana sulle strutture, alla base del trattato siglato con Tirana.

    È l’obiettivo del governo che ha deciso di modificare l’accordo con l’Albania e potrebbe farlo addirittura per decreto.

    Cercando una strada, dopo tre bocciature consecutive dei trattenimenti di migranti da parte dei giudici dell’Immigrazione e della Corte d’Appello, per escludere la competenza dei magistrati italiani sulla gestione dei profughi da rimpatriare. In queste ore si stanno esaminando varie ipotesi per far ripartire i trasferimenti di migranti, ma questa volta con un discorso più ampio che non prevede solo quelli soccorsi in mare e provenienti da Paesi inseriti nella lista italiana di quelli sicuri, ma anche coloro che già si trovano negli hotspot e nei centri di accoglienza sul territorio nazionale.

    Se n’è parlato in una riunione venerdì scorso, durante la quale è emersa la possibilità che i centri albanesi possano essere trasformati in cpr — dedicati quindi esclusivamente al rimpatrio dei profughi ritenuti senza requisiti per ottenere protezione internazionale dall’Italia — oppure in centri di accoglienza. E non si esclude a questo punto che possano essere gestiti da Tirana e non più da Roma.

    In tutti i casi, in attesa del parere dei giudici del Lussemburgo, l’esecutivo ribadisce la volontà di andare avanti. E per questo per oggi è stato programmato un altro vertice. Al centro dell’incontro forse anche la discussione sul nuovo decreto legge — ipotizzato fra gli altri dal ministro per gli Affari europei Tommaso Foti — che potrebbe nei piani del governo fornire una soluzione giuridica affidabile dopo le sentenze contrarie dei giudici sui trattenimenti in Albania.

    Ma le opposizioni attaccano. «Perseverare è diabolico, il governo fermi questa follia che sta creando uno scontro tra poteri senza precedenti e uno spreco di risorse», spiega Simona Bonafè, capogruppo dem in Commissione Affari costituzionali alla Camera, per la quale l’esecutivo «insiste nel tentativo inaccettabile di scegliersi i magistrati e riscrivere le regole in corsa». Per il capogruppo Avs nella stessa commissione, Filiberto Zaratti, «si sono cacciati in un pasticcio, smettano di sperperare i soldi degli italiani».

    Sul tavolo c’è anche la questione libica e le avvisaglie di una nuova ondata di partenze di migranti. I dati del Viminale confermano che gli arrivi nel 2025 sono superiori a quelli dello stesso periodo dello scorso anno: 4.144 contro 3.169. Sebbene nel mese in corso siano inferiori del febbraio 2024 (665 contro 2.301).

    Dalla «Relazione sulla situazione geopolitica del continente africano» approvata dal Copasir emerge che in Libia «sono presenti circa 700 mila immigrati irregolari» e altri «700-800 mila sono in Tunisia». Non pronti a partire, ma non si può escludere che alcuni possano rivolgersi ai canali criminali collegati agli scafisti. Tanto più che il Copasir sottolinea l’esistenza di «un legame fra le organizzazioni che sfruttano i flussi irregolari e quelle terroristiche che pretendono denaro quando le carovane transitano dai territori da loro controllati».

    Uno scenario preoccupante nel quale si inserisce ieri la scoperta di due fosse comuni a Jikharra e Kufra con almeno 49 corpi di migranti. Nella seconda, crocevia in Cirenaica di profughi subsahariani, con segni di tortura, mentre in 76 sono stati liberati dal lager dei trafficanti.

    Sempre ieri sono stati avvistati tre cadaveri in mare nell’Agrigentino, nel tratto poco distante da Marina di Palma dove la corrente ha trascinato un barcone utilizzato dai migranti.

    ▻https://www.corriere.it/politica/25_febbraio_10/sbarchi-accordo-albania-cambia-af8fe828-76b0-4a92-a148-9c8866b4bxlk.shtml

    #décret #nouveau_décret #Albanie #Italie #migrations #réfugiés #externalisation

    –-

    ajouté à la métaliste sur l’#accord entre #Italie et #Albanie pour la construction de #centres d’accueil (sic) et identification des migrants/#réfugiés sur le territoire albanais...

    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1043873

    • Migrants transferred from Albania appeal Italy protection denial

      Almost half of the migrants transferred from Albania to Italy on February 6 have filed an appeal against the rejection of their asylum requests. This happened on the same day that two migrants lost their lives while trying to reach Italy’s southern island of Lampedusa.

      On February 6, the first appeals were filed by some of the 43 migrants who had been transferred from Italy to a center in Albania before being moved back to Italy. These migrants, mostly from Bangladesh and Egypt, had their asylum applications rejected and were given a deadline to appeal — either by the evening of February 6 or February 7, depending on when they received the rejection notice.

      After a court annulled their detention orders in Albania’s Gjader repatriation center, the migrants were relocated to a facility in Bari, a southern port city in Italy.

      Earlier, on January 28, 49 migrants intercepted off Lampedusa were sent to Albania on the Italian patrol boat Cassiopeia. However, six of them — minors and individuals deemed vulnerable — were later brought back to Italy.

      The remaining migrants stayed only a few days in Albania before an appeals court in Rome suspended their detention while awaiting a decision from the European Court of Justice (ECJ) on whether Albania qualifies as a “safe” country for asylum seekers. This ruling led to their release and rendered the transfer to Albania ineffective.

      This was the third such transfer since October, but unlike before, the Italian government had expected a different result due to a legal change shifting the jurisdiction of the cases from the immigration court to the appeals court.

      Awaiting EU court ruling on ’safe’ country definition

      The key issue now is whether Bangladesh and Egypt, the migrants’ countries of origin, can be considered “safe.” Under a decree issued in December, Italy includes these nations on its official list of safe countries, meaning migrants from these regions can be subjected to fast-track asylum procedures and deported more quickly.

      However, the appeals court ruled that the decree did not consider the specific risks faced by certain groups of people in these countries. The European Court of Justice will now determine if these countries meet the necessary safety standards.

      Meanwhile, the journey of two other migrants tragically ended on February 6 in Lampedusa. They were among about 40 people who arrived on a small nine-meter boat. While most of the group was intercepted by authorities, one person died on the beach, and another passed away shortly after being taken to a clinic.

      ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/62742/migrants-transferred-from-albania-appeal-italy-protection-denial

      #justice

  • Les transferts de migrants vers les centres mis en place par l’#Italie en #Albanie reprennent

    Le navire militaire Cassiopea est en route vers le port de Shengjin, en Albanie, où seront accueillis les migrants secourus au large de Lampedusa. Les transferts reprennent le modèle introduit par les gouvernements Meloni et Rama.

    Le transfert des migrants vers les centres mis en place par l’Italie en Albanie a repris. Dans une note, le ministère italien de l’Intérieur a informé qu’après les opérations d’évaluation des conditions des personnes interceptées, 49 citoyens étrangers ont été embarqués à bord du navire Cassiopea au large de l’île de Lampedusa pour être transférés vers les centres en Albanie. C’est là que débuteront les procédures d’accueil, de détention et d’évaluation des cas individuels.

    Le Viminale, le ministère de l’Intérieur, a ensuite annoncé que 53 autres migrants avaient spontanément présenté leur passeport pour éviter d’être transférés. « Il s’agit d’une circonstance particulièrement importante, car elle permet d’activer plus rapidement les procédures de vérification des positions individuelles, même en dehors de la détention, augmentant ainsi les chances de procéder au rapatriement de ceux qui n’ont pas le droit de rester dans l’UE », peut-on lire dans la note.

    Les migrants à bord du navire devraient tous être de sexe masculin, adultes, sans vulnérabilité, en bonne santé et originaires de pays identifiés comme « sûrs ». Le navire les transférera vers le hotspot italien installé dans le port de Shengjin et, après les procédures d’identification, les demandeurs d’asile seront transférés vers le centre de Gjader.
    Meloni a sauvé le modèle albanais

    En novembre dernier, le modèle d’externalisation de l’accueil et du rapatriement des migrants a été bloqué pour la deuxième fois par le tribunal des migrants de Rome, avec la suspension de la détention en Albanie de sept migrants originaires d’Égypte et du Bangladesh.

    Pour éviter un nouveau blocage, le gouvernement de Giorgia Meloni a approuvé un décret-loi rebaptisé « décret sur les flux », qui contient une liste actualisée des « pays sûrs » pour les migrants, y compris l’Égypte et le Bangladesh, dans l’intention de contourner l’obstacle juridique imposé par la législation de l’UE avec une règle de rang supérieur à celle du précédent décret interministériel. La loi, qui est entrée en vigueur le 11 janvier, stipule que ce ne sont plus les magistrats de la section de l’immigration qui décideront, mais ceux de la Cour d’appel.

    ▻https://fr.euronews.com/my-europe/2025/01/26/les-transferts-de-migrants-vers-les-centres-mis-en-place-par-litalie-en
    #migrations #externalisation #asile #accord

    –-

    ajouté à la métaliste sur l’#accord entre #Italie et #Albanie pour la construction de #centres d’accueil (sic) et identification des migrants/#réfugiés sur le territoire albanais...

    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1043873

    • Italien bringt wieder Migranten ins Nicht-EU-Land Albanien

      Italiens rechtsgerichtete Regierung hat einen dritten Versuch unternommen, außerhalb der EU über Asylverfahren zu entscheiden. 49 Migranten wurden per Schiff in umstrittene Aufnahmezentren nach Albanien gebracht.

      Nach einer monatelangen Pause sind erneut Dutzende Asylsuchende von Italien in umstrittene Aufnahmezentren in Albanien gebracht worden. Am Dienstagmorgen lief ein Schiff der italienischen Marine mit 49 Flüchtlingen an Bord im Hafen der albanischen Stadt Shengjin ein, wie die italienische Nachrichtenagentur Ansa berichtete. Dort soll nun über deren Asylanträge entschieden werden.

      Bei den Migranten handelt es sich nach Angaben von Ansa um Männer aus Bangladesch, Ägypten, Gambia und der Elfenbeinküste. Vor der Fahrt nach Albanien waren sie auf dem Weg über das Mittelmeer nach Europa auf einem Boot vor der italienischen Mittelmeerinsel Lampedusa gestoppt worden.

      Seit vielen Jahren gehört Italien zu den Ländern, die von der Fluchtbewegung über das Mittelmeer besonders betroffen sind. Zwar kamen vergangenes Jahr deutlich weniger Migranten an Italiens Küsten an als noch 2023. Im Januar sind jedoch laut der Regierung in Rom wieder mehr als 3.000 Menschen dort eingetroffen - das sind mehr als doppelt so viele wie im gleichen Vorjahreszeitraum (etwa 1.300).
      Italiens Premierministerin Giorgia Meloni bei einem Treffen mit dem albanischen Premierminister Edi Rama

      Kontroverses „Albanien-Modell“

      Italien ist der erste Staat der Europäischen Union, der außerhalb der EU Lager errichtet hat, um dort über Asylanträge von Migranten zu entscheiden. Die rechtsgerichtete Ministerpräsidentin Giorgia Meloni und ihr albanischer Kollege Edi Rama hatten im November 2023 die Einrichtung der von Italien betriebenen Aufnahmelager für Asylbewerber in dem Nicht-EU-Land vereinbart.

      Das „Albanien-Modell“ ist umstritten. Menschenrechtsorganisationen kritisierten das Abkommen scharf. Die Lager zur Auslagerung der Asylverfahren gingen im Oktober in Betrieb, die ersten Überstellungen wurden aber von Gerichten gestoppt und die Menschen wieder nach Italien zurückgeschickt.
      Ein Dorf in Albanien empfängt erste Flüchtlinge für Italien

      Regierung versus Justiz

      Die ersten beiden Versuche waren an der Justiz gescheitert. Nach Auffassung der Richter kamen die nach Albanien gebrachten Migranten nicht aus sicheren Herkunftsländern, in die sie zurückgeschickt werden könnten. Die italienischen Richter beriefen sich in ihrer Entscheidung auf ein Urteil des Europäischen Gerichtshofs (EuGH) in Luxemburg, wonach Herkunftsländer von Migranten nur vollständig als sicher eingestuft werden können, nicht aber einzelne Landesteile.

      Um diese juristische Hürde künftig zu umgehen, verabschiedete Italiens Regierung ein Dekret, das alle Teile der 19 Länder, die auf der Liste der sicheren Herkunftsländer stehen, für „sicher“ erklärt. Richter fochten aber auch diese neue Regelung an.

      Auf Grund der ungeklärten Rechtslage ist daher wie bereits bei den ersten beiden Versuchen unklar, ob die Migranten wie eigentlich vorgesehen das beschleunigte Asylverfahren in den Lagern auf albanischem Boden durchlaufen oder doch nach Italien gebracht werden müssen. Der Europäische Gerichtshof will im Februar klären, ob das Vorgehen Italiens mit EU-Recht vereinbar ist.

      ▻https://www.dw.com/de/italien-bringt-wieder-migranten-ins-nicht-eu-land-albanien/a-71433244

    • Five people sent to Albania detention centers are returned to Italy

      Under the 2023 deal between Italy and Albania, adult males rescued in the Mediterranean Sea would be sent to Italian-run detention centers in Albania to have their asylum claims processed. Pregnant women and children, however, are exempted.

      An Italian navy ship with 49 people rescued in international waters docked in Albania on Tuesday (January 28) for the processing of their asylum applications, the Associated Press (AP) reported. Five of the passengers, however, were said to have been returned to Italy.

      Citing local media reports, AP said two Bangladeshis, two Gambians, and one Ivorian were sent back to Italy, four because they were minors. A fifth was reported to have been deemed a “vulnerable” person.

      The other 44 passengers who were reported to be mostly from Bangladesh, Egypt, Ivory Coast, and Gambia are being held at Albania’s Gjader facility, a former military airport, where their asylum applications will be processed.

      In line with the Italian - Albania deal ratified in 2024, only adult males rescued in the Mediterranean Sea could be sent to the Italian-run detention centers in Albania. People who are deemed “vulnerable” such as children, elderly, and the sick are exempted.
      ’Impossible to identify the vulnerable at sea’

      The Italian Juridical Association for Immigration Studies (ASGI), a group of independent lawyers and scholars focused on migrant rights, published a report last June raising concerns about the proposed procedure of assessing the needs of those rescued while at sea to determine their immediate transfer to Albania.

      “it is practically impossible to carry out a screening with respect to the identification of all vulnerabilities at the same time as rescue at sea ... Despite knowing that asylum seekers with special needs should be brought to Italy, it is already assumed that it will be impossible to identify them before disembarking in Shengjin,” ASGI wrote in the report.

      Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor, a youth-led human rights organization, outlined three contact points where rescued individuals are assessed for their vulnerability: one on the Italian Coast Guard vessel; one on the naval shop carrying people to Albania; and the last in the port of Schengjin.

      According to Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor, only those who visibly and undoubtedly fit the description of “vulnerable” such as women, children, elderly, and disabled persons would be exempted from being sent to Albania. People with hidden vulnerabilities such as mental disorders, and experience of torture of sexual violence would risk being subjected to border control procedures in prison-like centers.
      A third try

      The arrival of the Italian vessel marks the third attempt by Italy to implement its controversial 670 million euro ($730 million) deal with Albania to host migrant detention and processing centers.

      Last October and November, Italian judges refused to approve the detention of two groups of mostly Bangladesh and Egyptian men at the Albanian centers. In their ruling, the Court cited the European Court of Justice (ECJ) decisions on migrant safety to justify that the migrants’ countries of origin were not safe enough to return to should their asylum applications be rejected, because not all areas of the country could be considered safe.

      The ECJ is expected to assess whether Italy’s outsourcing of its migration and asylum policies to Albania aligns with EU laws in the coming weeks.

      Even before these legal tensions were brewing, two Italian prison officers’ unions—the Italian Autonomous Confederation of Penitentiary Police and the Officers’ Union Coordination—protested about the deployment of 50 correctional officers to Albania, saying the migrant centers were “like prison camps”.

      ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/62522/five-people-sent-to-albania-detention-centers-are-returned-to-italy

    • Migranti, i giudici non convalidano i trattenimenti in Albania: torneranno a Bari

      La decisione dei magistrati della Corte di Appello di Roma: giudizio sospeso e atti rinviati alla Corte di giustizia europea.

      I giudici della Corte di Appello di Roma hanno deciso di non convalidare i trattenimenti dei 43 migranti rinchiusi nei centri costruiti dall’Italia in Albania. E di rinviare gli atti alla Corte di giustizia europea. I migranti devono dunque essere liberati e saranno riportati, conferma il Viminale, in Italia, a Bari, su mezzi della guardia costiera.
      Il terzo no

      È il terzo no all’esperimento del governo Meloni che, nonostante due precedenti dinieghi, una sentenza della Cassazione che affidava sì ai ministri il compito di stilare la lista dei paesi sicuri ma anche ai giudici il dovere di verificarne la validità rispetto ai migranti e i rinvii pregiudiziali pendenti davanti alla Corte di giustizia europea, aveva deciso di forzare la mano. Muovendo un’altra volta, la terza, il pattugliatore della Marina militare da Lampedusa alle coste albanesi carico di un gruppetto di migranti.

      I giudici però hanno deciso ancora di annullare il fermo disposto dal questore, di sospendere il giudizio, rinviare la questione di nuovo all’Europa e liberare dunque i migranti.
      Il provvedimento

      “Il giudizio – si legge nel provvedimento firmato dai magistrati - va sospeso nelle more della decisione della Corte di Giustizia. Poiché per effetto della sospensione è impossibile osservare il termine di quarantotto ore previsto per la convalida, deve necessariamente essere disposta la liberazione del trattenuto, così come ha ripetutamente affermato la Corte Costituzionale in casi analoghi”.

      Alla Corte europea, che il 4 ottobre del 2024 aveva emesso una sentenza spiegando che un Paese può essere ritenuto sicuro solo se lo è in ogni sua parte di territori, i giudici chiedono se la direttiva vada interpretata in modo da dichiarare non sicuro anche un Paese in cui vi siano una o più categorie di persone minacciate o perseguitate.
      Le udienze

      Nel centro di Gjader, dei 49 migranti arrivati martedì scorso, ne erano rimasti 43, dopo che sei di loro erano stati ritrasferiti in Italia perché minorenni o vulnerabili e quindi non sottoponibili alla procedura accelerata di frontiera.

      Le udienze per la convalida dei trattenimenti erano iniziate nella prima mattinata di oggi. In videoconferenza si sono presentati i richiedenti asilo assistiti dai legali incaricati in extremis e sei magistrati della Corte d’appello di Roma, tutti pescati in realtà dalla sezione immigrazione del tribunale civile che era stata esautorata dal governo, modificando il codice di procedura penale, per scegliere giudici ritenuti meno politicizzati.
      Le richieste d’asilo respinte

      Le loro richieste di asilo erano state tutte giudicate già ieri “manifestamente infondate” dalla Commissione territoriale per l’esame dell’iter delle domande di protezione internazionale e dunque respinte. Ora i migranti avranno appena 7 giorni per fare ricorso contro il rigetto della loro domanda. Uno spazio di tempo che per l’Asgi (Associazione studi giuridici sull’immigrazione) rende «concretamente impossibile l’esercizio del diritto di difesa», in aperto contrasto con la Costituzione, la Cedu e le direttive europee.
      Le precedenti bocciature

      Nelle altre due precedenti occasioni, ad ottobre e a novembre, i giudici avevano sospeso il trattenimento e i migranti erano stati tutti riportati in Italia.

      La prima pronuncia risale al 18 ottobre e ha riguardato 12 richiedenti asilo bengalesi ed egiziani portati nel centro di Gjader. I giudici, si legge nelle ordinanze simili tra loro, hanno negato la convalida dei trattenimenti per «l’impossibilità di riconoscere come ’Paesi sicuri’ gli Stati di provenienza delle persone trattenute, con la conseguenza dell’inapplicabilità della procedura di frontiera e, come previsto dal protocollo, del trasferimento al di fuori del territorio albanese delle persone migranti, che hanno quindi diritto ad essere condotte in Italia».

      La seconda decisione è dell’11 novembre. Sette gli stranieri coinvolti, sempre egiziani e bengalesi. Rispetto al primo caso, il governo aveva nel frattempo emanato un decreto per definire la nuova lista di Paesi sicuri. Il provvedimento non è tuttavia servito ad evitare un esito diverso del giudizio.

      I magistrati hanno infatti sospeso il giudizio sulla convalida del trattenimento rimettendo tutto nelle mani della Corte di giustizia europea. Ma la sostanza non è cambiata: i richiedenti asilo sono stati liberati. Nello stesso tempo, i giudici hanno chiesto alla Corte di Lussemburgo chiarimenti sulla compatibilità, definita “dubbia”, del decreto del governo con le norme europee. Il 25 febbraio è attesa la pronuncia su questa materia da parte dell’organismo Ue.

      ▻https://www.repubblica.it/cronaca/2025/01/31/news/trattenimenti_migranti_albania_sentenza-423973949/?ref=RHLF-BG-P1-S1-T1
      #justice

    • Meloni’s Albania deportation experiment has failed

      Last Tuesday (28 January), as Giorgia Meloni’s government resumed its attempts to force people seeking safety and a better life in Europe into prison camps in Albania, electricity broke down in the port of Shengjin.

      As port staff struggled to get the lights back on, officials realised that among the people they were incarcerating were four children.

      They had to be taken to Italy — now the third time this has happened. The camps have sat empty since they were opened, home only to stray dogs.

      This power failure reflects the challenges facing Meloni’s plan. She has staked not only her moral standing but also her credibility on this deal succeeding, yet it continues to be mired in uncertainty and setbacks.

      On Friday (31 January), the courts ordered that the remaining 43 people taken to Albania were to be returned to Italy.

      Meloni has claimed that people exercising their legal right to claim asylum, or humanitarians providing aid, are criminals. But it is her attempt to strongarm her way past Italian and international law that has led to this mess.

      With each transfer to Albania, the government has claimed to only be returning non-vulnerable people to safe places.

      We know that no one who puts their life at risk in a sea crossing has come from a place of safety, and all face some form of risk.

      Italian authorities have proven incapable of even conducting a ‘proper’ selection process. Meloni’s government has managed to deport minors and vulnerable people to Albania time and again. Even with the deck stacked in their favour, they exposed the deal for what it truly is — an inhumane and reckless political stunt.

      And we know that the countries the government designates as “safe” are nothing of the sort, as the EU’s recent partial retreat on its Tunisia-funding has shown. Authorities in the country are selling sub-Saharan migrants as slaves, further fuelling a cycle of violence and exploitation.

      Some of those shipped to Albania come from Egypt, whose government routinely jails human rights activists and dissidents.

      Even after the Sisi regime’s security forces were infamously implicated in the death of an Italian student, Italian and EU politicians continued to fund those forces.

      Let’s also not forget that most of those arriving on Italian shores have fled Libya; where they have been tortured and even sold into slavery from camps supported by Italian and EU funds.

      These grim deals have fuelled human misery and have only made journeys more dangerous and deadly — which is why the Italian government is now placing all its hope in the Albania deal.
      Propaganda stunt

      It’s not just hope but hard cash that Meloni has thrown into the deal, which is set to cost the Italian public over €800m, with €100m squandered already. And other EU countries look set to follow suit.

      Who gains? Not people incarcerated in camps, not Albanians sold on false promises of regeneration in the camp towns, and not Italians who need affordable homes and secure jobs instead of more wasted resources.

      Beyond the political gains Meloni’s government hopes to reap from this propaganda stunt, the only economic beneficiaries are the corporate profiteers gouging the state to run camps, and perhaps the police agents being paid to lounge on the beach near empty facilities.

      All of this has been tried before. The shameful UK’s deal to fly asylum seekers to Rwanda ended in expensive and illegal failure, with not a single person deported.

      Australia’s offshore detention camps in Nauru — where people were held in brutal and squalid conditions at a cost of half a million Australian dollars per detainee — were found just this month to have violated international law by the UN’s human rights committee.

      In short, every time these deals have been tried, they have hurt — or even killed — people, broken the law, and redistributed public funds to rich contractors.

      Meloni’s reliance on Elon Musk to support the deal could not better symbolise how the wealthy and powerful scapegoat people crossing borders to divide us.

      The longer this deal exists, the more all of our rights are at risk. As someone who was imprisoned by the EU’s most authoritarian government on trumped-up charges, I know all too well the dangers involved in policies that lock people up with no due process.

      It’s not coincidental that the Meloni government is also seeking to drive through a sweeping attack on our civil liberties that begins with an attempt to ban detained migrants and prisoners from protesting the conditions they are being held in.

      The political energy and resources being spent on deportations and prisons in Albania should instead be going toward supporting people; both those born here and those seeking a better life here.

      And the naval ships ferrying people across the Adriatic could instead be used to rescue them, in a year where at least 2,200 more people have drowned on our doorstep.

      It’s time for Meloni’s government to face reality — this unlawful and, hopefully, unsuccessful plan is embarrassing Italy on the world stage. And as other European countries seek to copy Italy and produce their own return hubs, they should learn from our country’s cruel, expensive, experiment.

      ▻https://euobserver.com/migration/ar6aec9598

  • As Europe needs workers, Syrians face push to return

    With labor shortages across Europe, how can EU states balance calls to repatriate Syrians after the fall of Assad with the bloc’s workforce needs?

    Germany was quick to announce a pause in asylum applications from Syrian nationals following the fall of dictator Bashar Assad on December 8.

    Just 36 hours after Syrian rebels declared they had liberated the capital, Damascus, the German government suspended decisions on more than 47,000 pending asylum claims from Syrians. Within hours, France, Britain, Italy, and several others followed suit.

    The decisions heightened nervousness among the more than 1.5 million Syrians who have settled in Europe since the civil war began in 2011.

    Particularly alarming were remarks by Austrian Interior Minister Gerhard Karner, who instructed his ministry to prepare a program for the “orderly repatriation and deportation to Syria.” German politicians have made similar calls.

    European governments appeared to be seizing the moment of Assad’s ouster to address growing public unease over high migration rates.

    Even before the pause was announced, more than 108,000 asylum cases from Syrians were pending across EU states at the end of October, according to the European Union Agency for Asylum (EUAA).

    The swift decisions marked a stark contrast to the welcoming attitudes seen at the height of the 2015/16 European migrant crisis. Back then, Germans greeted Syrian refugees at railway stations with water bottles and food.
    No quick fix to Syria’s turmoil

    The announcements were even more unsettling given the ongoing chaos in Syria, where the leading rebel group, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), is struggling to establish a caretaker government.

    Compounding the situation was the apparent reversal of a key reason Europe wanted to welcome Syrian nationals. Beyond addressing humanitarian needs, politicians argued at the time that Syrians would help alleviate critical labor market shortages.

    Anastasia Karatzas, a policy analyst at the Brussels-based European Policy Center (EPC) think tank, noted that the European Union had recently stepped up efforts to return more refugees to their home countries before Assad’s removal despite the huge demand for more workers.

    “There’s an urgent need across the EU to address labor shortages, but also to address labor exploitation, especially of irregular migrant workers. But there is now a risk that prioritizing [refugee] returns might overshadow these other priorities,” Karatzas told DW.

    Integration of Syrians ’better than expected’

    Integrating such a large number of refugees — 972,000 Syrians in Germany’s case — in such a short period was certainly challenging. However, Philipp Jaschke, a labor market researcher at the Nuremberg-based Institute for Employment Research (IAB), thinks Germany’s efforts “worked much better than expected.”

    “[The refugees] left Syria suddenly. Many of them had traumatic experiences while escaping. When they arrived, they were largely unprepared for the German labor market, and there were many institutional barriers,” Jaschke told DW.

    Those hurdles included lengthy delays for asylum decisions, learning German, completing studies and obtaining recognized qualifications before entering the workforce, which takes years. In the meantime, refugees’ job prospects are often limited to low-skilled positions.

    IAB surveys suggest that back home, more than 90% of Syrians worked in occupations that require vocational training or a university degree in Germany. When they reached Germany, around a third initially worked in low-skilled jobs. Six years later, a quarter of them were still in these roles.
    Jobless rate high for multiple reasons

    As of September 2024, approximately 287,000 Syrians were employed in Germany, a report by the IAB published on December 13 revealed. Their average employment rate has fallen as large numbers arrived more recently and are still in the early phase of the integration process.

    The longer refugees remain in Germany, however, the more likely they are to find a job. IAB found that around 61% of Syrian refugees were employed seven years after their arrival.

    Although the 37% official jobless rate for Syrians is far higher than that of Germany’s national unemployment rate of 5.9% in November, cultural and other factors have played a significant role. More Syrian women than men are not in the workforce. Many held traditional family roles back home and have a lower likelihood of prior work experience. They’re also more likely to be mothers to young children.

    The EPC’s Karatzas said discrimination and “persistent difficulties with the recognition of skills and qualifications” were other issues, referring to Europe as a whole.

    Syrians fill key gaps in labor market

    In Germany, almost 30% of female refugees work in the social and cultural service sectors, including education and child care. One in 10 works in retail. More than one-fifth of male refugees work in logistics or manufacturing. Syrians also have a meaningful presence in the hospitality, health care, and construction sectors, according to the IAB.

    “These sectors have severe labor shortages,” Jaschke said, with a high demand for workers and a comparatively low labor supply. “So, Germany would really lose if these people left.”

    As to the question of how many would now like to return, a recent IAB-led survey found that more than 90% of Syrian-born refugees who entered Germany between 2013 and 2019 stated that they wanted to stay permanently. However, that could change as a result of the latest developments in Syria.

    “Almost 40% have lived here since 2015 or longer. They are making a living here, built social networks, many have brought their family, so it’s likely that many will stay,” Jaschke told DW.
    Too soon to talk about repatriation?

    Those who haven’t integrated into Europe or failed to find work in a reasonable time may be pushed to return or may want to return. Many more may be keen to help rebuild the Syrian economy from the nearly 14-year-long civil war. German conservative lawmaker Jens Spahn told broadcaster n-tv recently that they should be offered government support to repatriate and spoke of a relocation bonus of €1,000 ($1,055) per person and the use of government-chartered planes.

    As arguments continue to swirl over the issue, Frank Werneke warns against a large-scale repatriation effort. The head of Verdi, a German services union, hopes ministers will “approach the situation with a cool head.”

    In an interview with the German news agency DPA, Werneke said it was important that Syria’s transitional government first assemble “the mostdemocratic conditions as possible,” considering the needs of the country’s many ethnic and religious groups.

    At a European level, Karatzas is concerned that anti-migrant sentiment may prompt a knee-jerk reaction from many EU states and warned them against making hasty decisions.

    “Policies need to be made to ensure returns take place in a well-managed way, based on evidence and data about their [refugees] contributions [to the labor market].”

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/61766/as-europe-needs-workers-syrians-face-push-to-return

    #réfugiés #migrations #réfugiés_syriens #travail #main-d'oeuvre #Europe #économie #intégration #Allemagne #exploitation #intégration_professionnelle #chômage

    ping @karine4

    –-

    ajouté à ce fil de discussion :
    En #Allemagne, la #crainte d’un potentiel départ de Syriens, notamment dans le domaine de la santé
    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1090181

  • Is Italy’s model for offshoring migrants doomed to fail ?

    Italy’s right-wing government has once again failed to outsource the processing of asylum applications to non-EU countries. The costly project has already drawn legal fire. Now, the Court of Auditors has intervened.

    It was an embarrassing defeat for Italy’s government. Just weeks ago, at an EU summit, far-right Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni had been promoting her “innovative” approach to processing asylum applications in non-EU third countries.

    But now, the processing and detention facilities constructed in Albania expressly for this purpose are empty once again — save a few Italian staff members.

    In October, Meloni’s government had been forced to return the first 16 asylum-seekers it was holding in Albania back to Italy. Four claimed to be minors or ill. A court in Rome ruled that the remaining 12 asylum-seekers had the right to a trial in Italy.

    In early November, the ring-wing administration made a second attempt, and transferred seven adults from Bangladesh and Egypt to a detention center in Albania. Days later, the government had to backtrack when a court in Rome ordered all seven be returned to Italy. A naval ship took them to the port of Brindisi, in southern Italy.

    Judges in Rome have now sought clarification on the issue from European Court of Justice in Luxembourg.

    At full capacity, Italy’s government had hoped its facilities in Albania would be able to process up to 40,000 asylum applications a year. But not even two months into the launch of the project, it remains unclear whether the centers will ever be used.
    Right-wing governing alliance attacks judiciary

    “Now, the right move for Meloni’s government would be to say, ’OK, we tried, but it’s just not possible’,” said Christopher Hein, a professor of migration and asylum law at Luiss University in Rome.

    Both the European Court of Justice and various Italian courts have expressed concerns over Italy’s classification of safe countries of origin, he explained, “especially with regard to Egypt and Bangladesh, as well as Tunisia, which is a key country of origin for asylum-seekers in Italy.”

    Italy’s three-way, right-wing governing alliance has now launched an attack on the country’s judiciary, with which it has been at loggerheads over other issues as well.

    Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini, the leader of the right-wing Lega (League) party, who faces a prison sentence for his 2019 treatment of migrants during his tenure as interior minister, said the courts’ decisions were politically motivated, and would affect Italian security.

    The somewhat more moderate minister for foreign affairs, Antonio Tajani, meanwhile, spoke of “a few judges who want to impose their political line on the government.”

    Tech billionaire Elon Musk, who has been tapped to lead a new Department of Government Efficiency in the new administration of US President-elect Donald Trump, has now also weighed in on the controversy, posting on his social media platform X, “[t]hese judges need to go.”
    Italy-Albania agreement had no ’deterrent effect’

    Meloni’s Albania model is not the only way Italy’s government under the post-fascist Brothers of Italy party has tried to clamp down on irregular migration.

    For example, since assuming office in 2022, Meloni has passed legislation that tightly restricts sea rescue. Now, ships are obliged to conclude their missions as soon as they have brought shipwrecked people aboard. These ships are frequently assigned to distant ports in northern Italy, which makes their operations more costly and less efficient.

    A speaker for the UN International Organization for Migration told DW that far fewer arrivals had been recorded this year than in the same period last year.

    However, the spokesperson also explained that: “considering the arrivals recorded over the past month, which was, in any case, characterized by bad weather, we can say that, at present, the Italy-Albania agreement has not had a deterrent effect, given that over the last 11 days alone, more than 3,300 sea arrivals have been recorded in Italy.”

    The spokesperson added that, when looking at the number of irregular migrants arriving, Europe was still a far cry from the emergency situation witnessed in 2015.
    Italy’s agreement mirrors UK’s Rwanda asylum plan

    Italy’s agreement with its neighbor across the Adriatic still seems to appeal to other European governments. Denmark, the Netherlands and some politicians in Germany have also started expressing their own thoughts on involving third countries as a sort of service provider for offloading migrant caseloads.

    Italy has set a precedent within the EU, and is therefore receiving as much attention as the UK did with its controversial Rwanda deal. Just this summer, London finally scrapped plans to deport asylum-seekers to Rwanda. But that was only after the former Tory government had sunk £700 million (€830 million/$888 million) of public funds in the undertaking.

    “The legal, logistical and financial difficulties — and the Albania model has shown this — are so high, that the whole thing isn’t worth it,” said legal expert Hein.

    He added that these were “desperate attempts to deal with the migrant and asylum situation in a way that did not do justice to those seeking asylum, or the legitimate need of the population for a more orderly procedure.”
    Will Meloni lose millions in Albania?

    Italy’s Albania model is also on the verge of become a financial disaster. The government currently expects operating costs to run up to €500 million by 2029. Now, the Court of Auditors, the highest audit institution in the heavily indebted EU member state, has intervened.

    Hein spoke of a glaring disproportion between expenditure and the number of asylum-seekers involved. “This could even have consequences under criminal law,” he cautioned.

    As a result of its inquiries, the Court of Auditors would also have the authority to prohibit further spending, the expert added.

    In the coming weeks, Italy’s Supreme Court of Cassation, the country’s highest court of appeal, will rule on whether national laws on safe countries of origin are in line with EU legislation. Decisions by the European Court of Justice on the matter are also outstanding.

    Soon, the decision over whether to continue with the Albania model may no longer be up to Italy’s government.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/61224/is-italys-model-for-offshoring-migrants-doomed-to-fail
    #cour_des_comptes #Albanie #Italie #accord #externalisation #migrations #réfugiés #asile

    –-

    ajouté à la métaliste sur l’#accord entre #Italie et #Albanie pour la construction de #centres d’accueil (sic) et identification des migrants/#réfugiés sur le territoire albanais...

    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1043873

  • Meloni’s government passes new law to save Albania migration transfer policy

    Move by Italian PM overturns ruling by a Rome court that could have blocked deal to curb migrant arrivals

    Italy’s far-right government has passed a new law to overcome a court ruling that risks blocking the country’s multimillion-dollar deal with Albania aimed at curbing migrant arrivals.

    On Friday, a court in Rome ruled to transfer back to Italy the last 12 asylum seekers being held in the new Italian migration hub in Albania. The ruling has cast doubt on the feasibility and legality of plans by the EU to explore ways to establish migrant processing and detention centres outside the bloc as part of a new hardline approach to migration.

    The group of individuals, who had arrived at the port of Shëngjin from Lampedusa onboard a military vessel last week, were among the 16 people transferred for the first time to the designated facility in Gjadër under the agreement between Italy’s prime minister, Giorgia Meloni, and the Albanian prime minister, Edi Rama, aimed at holding men who are intercepted in international waters while trying to cross from Africa to Europe.

    Four of the 16 men were immediately sent back to Italy on Thursday, including two who were underage and two who were deemed as vulnerable.

    The remaining 12 individuals whom the Rome judges ordered be transferred back to Italy were returned via the port of Bari on Saturday in a blow to Meloni that risks turning the initiative into what aid workers and opposition groups have deemed a “complete failure” and a “financial disaster”.

    Meloni’s party, the far-right Brothers of Italy, angrily condemned the decision on social media, blaming “politicised magistrates” who “would like to abolish Italy’s borders. We will not allow it.”

    Italy’s justice minister, Carlo Nordio, attacked the judges, saying “the definition of a safe country cannot be up to the judiciary”.

    The dispute that has sparked the clash revolves around the definition of what constitutes “safe countries” of origin. The 16 asylum seekers hailed from Egypt and Bangladesh, countries deemed safe by Italy, and therefore, according to the government, they should have been repatriated to their countries of origin.

    However, the judges ordered their transfer to Italy, saying the men could be at risk of violence if repatriated, effectively upholding the 4 October ruling of the European court of justice that the Italian government appeared to have overlooked. As a general rule, EU law takes precedence over conflicting national laws.

    The EU court made it clear that a country not entirely safe cannot be deemed safe, underlining that the condition of insecurity, even if limited to a specific part of the country, such as a certain region, could lead to the entire country being deemed unsafe.

    The council of ministers approved the decree after an emergency meeting held late Monday afternoon. The aim of the new law is to draw up a new list of safe countries, which can be updated every six months, and to allow a court of appeal to reconsider rulings that order the transfer of asylum seekers to Italy. From now on, the country of origin will be a primary condition for repatriation. Meloni’s government hopes in this way to bind the magistrates’ decision to government decrees and not to international laws.

    “In compliance with the ruling of the European court of justice, countries that contain unsafe territorial areas are excluded from the list: Nigeria, Cameroon and Colombia,” said the undersecretary to the presidency of the council, Alfredo Mantovano, in a press conference at Palazzo Chigi after the council of ministers’ meeting.

    Meloni said: “We will continue to work tirelessly to defend our borders.”

    The row between the judges and the government escalated further on Sunday when Meloni published excerpts on social media of a letter sent by one prosecutor to a group which includes judges.

    In it, Judge Marco Patarnello warned that Meloni was “stronger and much more dangerous” than the former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, who faced frequent legal woes and who repeatedly attacked the judiciary.

    Rightwing politicians said the letter proved the legal bias against the government.

    Critics said however that Meloni did not post the rest of the text, in which Patarnello said “we must not engage in political opposition, but we must defend jurisdiction and the citizens’ right to an independent judge”.

    On Monday, the president of the judiciary’s union, Giuseppe Santalucia, said: “We are not against the government, it would be absurd to think that the judiciary, an institution of the country, is against an institution of the country like political power.”

    ▻https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/oct/21/meloni-rushes-to-pass-new-law-to-save-albania-migration-transfer-policy

    #Italie #Albanie #externalisation #accord #migrations #asile #réfugiés #frontières #decret #pays-sûrs

    –-

    ajouté à la métaliste sur l’#accord entre #Italie et #Albanie pour la construction de #centres d’accueil (sic) et identification des migrants/#réfugiés sur le territoire albanais...

    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1043873

    • CPR in Albania. Paesi “sicuri” per decreto legge

      I fatti sono noti: il fermo dei primi migranti, che la Libra, nave della Marina militare italiana, aveva portato in Albania non è stato convalidato dal tribunale di Roma. Nel CPR albanesi, secondo quanto stabilito dagli accordi con il governo di Tirana, potrebbero finire solo uomini adulti provenienti da paesi “sicuri”.
      Paesi “sicuri” sono quelli inclusi in una lista stilata dal governo.
      In base al parere della Corte europea giustizia sulla direttiva UE in materia di paesi “sicuri” che stabilisce che non possono esservi paesi assolutamente sicuri per tutt*, il tribunale di Roma ha obbligato il governo a trasferire in fretta in Italia e furia il gruppetto di uomini provenienti da Bangladesh ed Egitto, rinchiusi nel CPR di Gjader.
      La risposta del governo non si è fatta attendere. Ieri è stato emesso un decreto legge, quindi immediatamente in vigore, sino alla scontata convalida del parlamento, in cui viene definita per legge la lista dei paesi “sicuri”.
      Nei fatti il governo se ne infischia del merito e va dritto allo scopo: selezionare, rinchiudere e deportare esseri umani in eccesso per mantenere il consenso nel proprio elettorato.

      ►https://radioblackout.org/2024/10/cpr-in-albania-paesi-sicuri-per-decreto-legge

    • L’Italie publie un nouveau décret sur les « pays sûrs » pour sauver son accord avec l’Albanie

      Le gouvernement italien a publié lundi un nouveau décret visant à sauver son accord avec l’Albanie, qui prévoit l’externalisation des demandes d’asile dans ce pays voisin. L’exécutif a dévoilé une nouvelle liste de pays considérés comme « sûrs » pour envoyer les ressortissants originaires de ces États vers l’Albanie, sans être contrecarré par une décision de justice. Mais les juristes estiment que cette modification législative risque quand même de poser de nouvelles questions juridiques.

      Le gouvernement italien contre-attaque. La coalition au pouvoir, alliant droite et extrême droite, a adopté lundi 21 octobre en Conseil des ministre un décret qui inscrit dans la loi 19 pays considérés comme « sûrs » par Rome pour y rapatrier les migrants.

      Un moyen pour le gouvernement de sauver son accord avec l’Albanie, mis à mal par une décision de justice vendredi. Un tribunal romain a en effet invalidé la rétention des 12 premiers migrants arrivés sur le sol albanais mercredi 16 octobre, après avoir été interceptés en Méditerranée par les autorités italiennes. Ces hommes, originaires d’Égypte et du Bangladesh, ont dû être rapatriés en Italie trois jours plus tard.

      Les juges italiens se sont appuyés sur un récent arrêt de la Cour européenne de justice (CJUE), qui estime que le Bangladesh et l’Égypte ne sont pas des pays sûrs, contrairement à l’Italie.

      Nouvelle liste de pays « sûrs »

      Afin de se conformer à la législation européenne, l’exécutif italien a exclu aujourd’hui trois pays parmi les 22 de sa liste précédente de « pays sûrs ». Désormais, le #Cameroun, la #Colombie et le #Nigeria en sont exclus. Toutefois, la nouvelle liste, qui a vocation à être mise à jour annuellement, comprend toujours le #Bangladesh, la #Tunisie et l’#Egypte.

      Le décret ministériel, dont l’entrée en vigueur est immédiate, vise « à garantir que le recours à la demande de protection ne soit pas largement exploité pour échapper à la justice », a déclaré le ministre de l’Intérieur, Matteo Piantedosi.

      Mais ce nouveau texte suffira-t-il à contrer la justice, comme le souhaite la Première ministre Giorgia Meloni ? Selon des juristes, cette modification législative risque de poser de nouvelles questions juridiques, et même avec ce décret, c’est bien la législation européenne qui prévaut malgré tout.

      « Magistrats politisés »

      La décision de la justice italienne est un revers cinglant pour la cheffe du gouvernement, qui a fait de la lutte contre l’immigration irrégulière sa priorité.

      « Je ne crois pas qu’il soit de la compétence des juges de décider quels pays sont sûrs et lesquels ne le sont pas, c’est une compétence du gouvernement », avait-t-elle déclaré, alors que son parti avait dénoncé une décision « absurde » et fustigé des « magistrats politisés ».

      De son côté, le ministre de la Justice Carlo Nordio a dénoncé « un arrêt de la Cour de Justice européenne qui est complexe, très détaillé et qui n’a probablement pas été bien compris ni bien lu ».

      L’accord avec Tirana, qui a du plomb dans l’aile, était pourtant présenté comme un exemple à suivre au sein de l’Union européenne (UE). Depuis quelques jours, les États membres - dont certains veulent appliquer le modèle italien - ont les yeux rivés sur l’Italie, et sur sa possibilité ou non d’externaliser les demandes d’asile dans un pays hors UE.

      ►https://www.infomigrants.net/fr/post/60711/litalie-publie-un-nouveau-decret-sur-les-pays-surs-pour-sauver-son-acc

    • Italy: What next for the government’s Albania plan?

      The Italian government’s plan to process asylum seekers in Albania has hit a stumbling block. The government insists it will go ahead anyway, but if it is contrary to EU law, can it really proceed? InfoMigrants asked an expert from the Italian juridical association ASGI.

      Italy claims its Albania plan is in step with European policy, but Italian judges have ruled that legally, it contravenes European and human rights law. Where does the plan go from here?

      An Italian naval ship, the Libra, is currently docked in Sicily. According to the Italian news agency ANSA, the ship is waiting for orders to move just outside Italy’s national waters, to take more migrants rescued on their way to Italy towards the centers in Albania.

      But given the decision by Rome’s tribunal last week, ordering migrants taken to Albania back to Rome to have their claims processed, can the Albanian system really work?

      Lucia Gennari is a lawyer and associate with ASGI, the Italian Association for Juridical Studies on Immigration. InfoMigrants put some of its questions to her:

      IM: The Italian government says it wants to go ahead, but can it, legally speaking?

      LG: Well, they passed a new decree on Monday. So, it seems that the way they are hoping to move ahead is to enshrine a list of safe countries of origin in law. But we know that judges are not obliged to apply [Italian] laws that might go against European Union principles and judgments and directives.

      To us the passing of this decree seems to be less about substantially changing things, from a legal perspective, and more about signaling that if there is a decision in the future where a judge rules that the person who comes from a country on the list should have their asylum claim heard anyway, they can accuse the courts of being politicized and trying to interfere with the policies of government.

      What they did with this decree was remove countries from the list that had territorial exceptions, arguing that the EU Court of Justice (ECJ) ruling referenced by the Rome Tribunal applied only to these territorial restrictions. This is true, but also the ECJ was very clear that for a country to be considered safe, it has to “uniformly and systematically respect” human and civil rights.

      There is also an ongoing case before the ECJ on this very topic. It is very likely that there will be a second [European] decision that will exclude the possibility of considering a country safe when there are exceptions for certain categories of people. We have for example Bangladesh, which has a lot of exempted categories of people.

      The other thing they did, was to include the possibility of appealing at the court of appeal the possibility of administrative detention. Before you could only appeal at the high court, and that takes a long time. So previously, if a judge decided to revalidate the detention of someone, there was no way for the state to restart that detention. The new decree would make that possible.

      So, I think this is how they are hoping to keep going with the Albania protocol.

      IM: The navy has a ship waiting in Augusta, is it possible for the Italian government to send that ship out and pick up more people? Or are they perhaps waiting for nationals from countries that are not Egypt and Bangladesh to try and take them to Albania?

      LG: I don’t know why they are waiting. Perhaps it is because there is currently bad weather in the Mediterranean and perhaps there are not so many departures. I don’t think it is about trying to find nationals from other countries, because the logic will be the same.

      The mechanism is that they collect people who were rescued by other smaller Italian ships. The people are selected on board the rescue ship and some are brought to the Libra and some are sent to Lampedusa and others are sent back to Albania, but they have to be in international waters.

      IM: Does the Italian government’s decree regarding safe countries remind you of the former British government’s attempts to declare Rwanda safe above the ruling of the supreme court?

      LG: Yes, I don’t know in detail the mechanism for Rwanda. I think there are some differences, and perhaps the Italian government learned from the Rwanda plan, which failed completely. There is one crucial difference between Rwanda and Albania, and that is that in the Italian government’s plan, everyone who is brought to Albania, there is this fiction that they are still on Italian territory. All the laws that apply are the same as in Italy. It’s Italian law, the procedures are the same, at least theoretically. I think in practice there are probably a lot of differences, but, the UK wanted to hand over their responsibility of assessment of asylum claims to the Rwandan authorities, and this is a very big difference.

      ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/60808/italy-what-next-for-the-governments-albania-plan

  • Spain asks #Frontex to patrol African waters to curb migration

    Spain has asked EU border agency Frontex to seek permission from West African nations to patrol their seas. It hopes this will stop migrants from reaching the Canary Islands.

    Spain’s interior minister, Fernando Grande-Marlaska, has asked the European border agency Frontex to try to obtain permission to patrol some West African coastlines in order to help with those countries’ own migration management efforts.

    EU agreements with some West African countries, spearheaded by Spain, already provide for support with training and patroling the sea borders.

    The Spanish authorities said they were making this request in a bid to “save lives,” reported the news agency Reuters.

    Grande-Marlaska pointed out that Frontex operated in African territory in 2006, when a large number of people were leaving the continent. He said Frontex should approach Mauritania, Senegal and Gambia – the major departure countries for people crossing to the Canary Islands – for new permissions.

    In 2022, the NGO Statewatch claimed that Frontex was already planning operations in Mauritania and Senegal.

    ’Improve capacity to act abroad’

    The interior minister said he believed that Frontex could only truly protect Europe’s borders if it was able to operate outside of them as well, reported Reuters. “It is particularly important to improve its capacity to act abroad, both in terms of return and border management,” Grande-Marlaska said during a meeting of EU interior ministers in Luxembourg on October 10.

    At least 31,215 migrants have reached the Canary Islands this year. The figure is higher than last year, but still substantially under the number arriving in Italy (52,108), according to the UN refugee agency, UNHCR.

    UN Migration’s Missing Migrants project says at least 781 people have died on the Atlantic route towards the Canary Islands since the beginning of the year. The actual number could be much higher, since there is no official register of who sets off, and with such a vast route, no way of knowing how many boats, or people, have disappeared.

    Dangerous Atlantic crossing

    The Spanish human rights organization Caminando Fronteras (Walking Borders) estimates that in the first five months of 2024, at least 5,054 people died trying to reach Spain through various routes, the main one being the Atlantic route.

    In September, a boat overturned off El Hierro in the Canary Islands as it was approached by rescuers. Nine people were found dead on arrival, and at least 48 others were unaccounted for. This was the deadliest such incident in 30 years of crossing this route, reports Reuters.

    The request from Spain to Frontex comes just a day after the Spanish prime minister, Pedro Sanchez, spoke in positive terms about migrants and migration, underlining in a speech in parliament that Spain needed migrants to secure the future of its country and economic growth.

    Sanchez told parliamentarians that they should look to the facts about migrants, emphasizing that the majority of migrants to Spain came via legal routes. However he also said that it was important to manage migration properly and that he planned to urge the EU to speed up the implementation of the new pact on migration and asylum.

    Increasing returns

    The new pact provides for an increase in funding and presence of Frontex officers, and also proposes the creation of faster assessment processes at borders.

    An EU interior ministers’ conference in Luxembourg this week discussed the possibility of creating return centers or deportation hubs at the EU’s external borders. The Belgian minister responsible for asylum and migration, Nicole de Moor, described Europe’s returns process as the “weakest link” in its migration management policy.

    Last year, according to European data, more than 500,000 people in the EU were issued with notices to quit European territory. Only 20 percent of those issued with the notices actually did so.

    Frontex assesses future strategic risks

    In a strategic risk analysis report from Frontex published at the end of September, the agency writes that it expects “migratory pressures…to increase.” It says this will require “substantial improvements in border management capabilities.”

    The report underlines that cooperation with third countries – in areas such as border control and surveillance, capacity building and training, as well as “return activities” – will be crucial to the EU to manage migration in the future.

    The agency also worries that the influence of authoritarian regimes, already present in Burkina Faso, Mali and Niger, could spread. This could “stir sociopolitical tensions, unrest and civil war, triggering intra-Africa displacements and/or irregular migration flows outside the continent, mainly towards Europe on the Central and Western Mediterranean routes.”

    The report does not mention any specific states in which Frontex patrols are planned.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/60504/spain-asks-frontex-to-patrol-african-waters-to-curb-migration

    #Espagne #migrations #frontières #externalisation #contrôles_frontaliers #îles_Canaries #Canaries #route_Atlantique

  • Il ruolo dell’#Unhcr nei centri in Albania, tra le “lettere” con il governo e le vittime di tratta

    Non c’è alcun protocollo siglato dal ministero dell’Interno ma uno scambio epistolare, ottenuto da Altreconomia, in cui si definisce l’intervento che l’Agenzia Onu per i rifugiati dovrebbe svolgere nelle contestate strutture per migranti di #Shëngjin e #Gjadër. “Era doverosa la nostra presenza”, spiega Chiara Cardoletti dell’Unhcr. Resta però il punto estremamente critico delle persone “vulnerabili”

    Nessun protocollo, solo uno “scambio di lettere”. La presenza del personale dell’Alto commissariato delle Nazioni Unite per i rifugiati (Unhcr) nei centri per migranti di Shëngjin e Gjadër in Albania si basa su una semplice dichiarazione di intenti “in assenza di una formale stipula d’accordo”.

    Scrive così il ministero dell’Interno rispondendo alla richiesta di Altreconomia di poter visionare la documentazione relativa al ruolo che l’Unhcr rivestirà nell’ambito dell’accordo tra Roma e Tirana.

    “Non è stato siglato un protocollo perché l’Unhcr non fa parte dell’accordo Italia-Albania -spiega ad Altreconomia Chiara Cardoletti, Rappresentante per l’Italia, la Santa Sede e San Marino dell’agenzia Onu per i rifugiati-. Dopo aver ricevuto chiarimenti su alcuni aspetti del Protocollo anche in sede parlamentare, alla luce di incontri durante i quali il governo ha ribadito la forte volontà che questo sia in linea con il diritto e gli standard internazionali, si è ritenuto più opportuno procedere con uno scambio di lettere con il ministero dell’Interno per definire le nostre funzioni”.

    Proprio a firma di Cardoletti è la lettera inviata il 7 agosto al ministero dell’Interno e ottenuta da Altreconomia. L’Unhcr esprime “gratitudine per l’invito esteso dal Governo italiano” che permette di “contribuire alla protezione delle persone coinvolte nell’attuazione del Protocollo”. Osserva in apertura che qualsiasi accordo tra Stati relativo alle persone soccorse o intercettate al mare “deve essere conforme al diritto internazionale dei rifugiati, ai diritti umani nonché agli standard di protezione”.

    Molti giuristi ritengono che lo stesso protocollo violi il diritto internazionale ma Cardoletti, a nostra specifica richiesta, ha risposto che “molto dipenderà da come questo protocollo verrà implementato e proprio per questo consideriamo importante il nostro ruolo di monitoraggio”.

    Che cosa farà l’Unhcr? Nelle lettere si indica attività di monitoraggio e di counselling attraverso personale qualificato dell’Agenzia che sarà presente sia sulla “nave hub” che trasferirà i migranti verso il territorio albanese così come nei centri di Shëngjin e Gjadër in Albania “e in qualsiasi altra località che possa diventare rilevante nell’attuazione del Protocollo in questione”. Non è chiaro, in questa frase, a quale struttura si riferisca l’Alto commissariato.

    Il governo italiano, dal canto suo, dovrà condividere regolarmente “tutte le informazioni pertinenti” inclusi “i dati statistici relativi all’attuazione del Protocollo”. L’intervento è previsto per un periodo di tre mesi dalla data in cui questo diventerà operativo e l’Unhcr si riserva il diritto “a sua completa discrezione, di ritirarsi da questa intesa in qualsiasi momento” in caso diventi necessario “per motivi operativi, gestionali o di altra natura”.

    L’Alto commissariato fornirà a Roma “osservazioni e raccomandazioni” che contribuiranno “ove necessario” a promuovere l’adesione al diritto internazionale e agli standard pertinenti” nell’attuazione del Protocollo.

    La risposta da Roma non si fa attendere. E il 12 agosto la prefetta Laura Lega, a capo del Dipartimento per le libertà civili e l’immigrazione, sottolinea che la presenza di Unhcr “costituirà un sicuro valore aggiunto per l’attuazione del Protocollo” che si pone come obiettivo quello di sviluppare “un innovativo modello di gestione dei flussi migratori nel pieno rispetto del diritto e degli standard internazionali”.

    A proposito di tali garanzie c’è un altro punto delicato. Come raccontato da Altreconomia è prevista infatti la possibilità di trasferire anche i cosiddetti “vulnerabili” -citati tra l’altro anche dall’Unhcr nella sua lettera- viste le attività garantite dalla Medihospes Albania Srl proprio per questa tipologia di persone.

    “Abbiamo ricevuto garanzie e rassicurazione su questo punto di vista e il Protocollo prevede, in ogni modo che le persone vulnerabili siano portate in Italia”, sottolinea Cardoletti che però specifica che non sarà compito dell’Unhcr “identificare le vulnerabilità che spetta ai soggetti attuatori del protocollo, quindi alle autorità”, aggiungendo che l’Agenzia sarà pronta “a intervenire se le necessità o i diritti dei vulnerabili non saranno garantiti”.

    Questo è un punto molto scivoloso, fa notare Maria Grazia Giammarinaro, già magistrata e Special Rapporteur delle Nazioni Unite sulla tratta di esseri umani dal 2014 al 2020. “Non comprendo la posizione dell’Unhcr sulle persone vulnerabili -spiega ad Altreconomia-. Identificare le condizioni che garantiscono il diritto d’asilo implica inevitabilmente esaminare anche le vulnerabilità. D’altra parte, proprio in Italia, l’Agenzia ha avuto un ruolo di primo piano nella costruzione e implementazione di Linee guida che facilitassero l’identificazione e il referral delle vittime di tratta durante le procedure di asilo. E l’essere vittima di tratta, secondo la giurisprudenza di molti tribunali, è a sua volta un presupposto per il riconoscimento dello status di rifugiato”.

    In risposta a un accesso dell’Associazione per gli studi giuridici sull’immigrazione (Asgi), il Dipartimento per le libertà civili e l’immigrazione in seno al Viminale ha provato a chiarire chi si occuperà dei vulnerabili, specificando nuovamente che i minori non verranno trasferiti in Albania (dove però sono presenti, secondo i documenti di Medihospes, dei fasciatoi) chiarendo che a bordo della nave sarà svolta un’attività di pre-screening coordinata da funzionari della polizia, “coadiuvato da personale specializzato per gli aspetti sanitari e la mediazione linguistico-culturale”.

    Una volta arrivati in Albania, invece, interverranno “diversi attori” per identificare quei casi in cui “una vulnerabilità emergesse successivamente presso le strutture site in Albania, il migrante verrà trasferito sul territorio italiano”.

    Oltre all’Ufficio di sanità marittima, aerea e di frontiera del ministero della Salute, ci sarà l’Istituto nazionale per la promozione della salute delle popolazioni migranti che a fine luglio ha aggiudicato una gara da oltre due milioni di euro per l’affidamento di un “servizio medico ed infermieristico presso l’istituto detentivo di Gjadër” alla Croce Bianca Srl, con sede a Roma.

    E infine il Dipartimento indica il personale dell’ente gestore “per la ricerca attiva di vulnerabilità sanitarie che dovessero verificarsi durante la permanenza” o in “collaborazione con psicologi e altri specialisti” per l’emersione di violenza e tratta. Su questo punto, però, non è chiaro come si procederà. L’ufficio del Viminale cita il “Vademecum per la rilevazione, il referral e la presa in carico delle persone portatrici di vulnerabilità”.

    Questo documento, siglato nel giugno 2023, prevede con riferimento alle vittime di tratta (la cui identificazione è spesso complicata perché vivono la “paura” delle minacce subite dai trafficanti) che laddove è presente l’Oim (Organizzazione mondiale per le migrazioni) sia suo compito svolgere la prima intervista alla potenziale vittima, come succede ad esempio sulle coste siciliane. Laddove però l’Oim non c’è, come nel caso albanese, “la prima intervista può essere condotta dal personale che ha momentaneamente in carico la potenziale vittima in coordinamento con le associazioni anti-tratta a cui è possibile fare una segnalazione attraverso l’utilizzo di materiale informativo”.

    Il documento cita il Numero verde, un dispositivo attivo giorno e notte a cui è possibile segnalare i casi. “Nessuno ci ha contattato per informarci o chiedere supporto su questo”, spiega però Gianfranco Della Valle, referente del numero del numero verde nazionale antitratta.

    Così come nessuno ha contattato il Dipartimento per le pari opportunità, titolare dei progetti per le vittime di tratta. Non solo: il numero verde non funziona se la chiamata arriva dall’estero. “Qualunque vademecum si voglia utilizzare c’è un problema alla radice -riprende Giammarinaro-. Per identificare le vulnerabilità, e soprattutto le vittime di tratta, sono necessari vari colloqui con operatori sociali qualificati, è necessario costruire un rapporto di fiducia che porti alla condivisione del proprio vissuto di sfruttamento. Questo certamente non può avvenire in mare dopo il salvataggio e men che meno una volta arrivati in Albania, data l’approssimazione metodologica con la quale il problema viene affrontato e l’incertezza sui soggetti che se ne faranno carico. Penso che sarà quasi impossibile identificare una vittima di tratta nel contesto di questo Protocollo”.

    Per Cardoletti di Unhcr “la fase di identificazione e screening sarà decisiva, soprattutto a bordo delle navi” e risulta “evidente l’importanza del ruolo di monitoraggio dell’Agenzia che permetterà di verificare il rispetto effettivo dei diritti dei soggetti a cui si applica il Protocollo”.

    La linea che separa il monitoraggio all’avallo del protocollo è però molto sottile. A inizio settembre il sottosegretario al ministero dell’Interno Nicola Molteni ha detto a La Stampa che in Libia e Tunisia “la politica migratoria avviene in un quadro di politiche internazionali con il controllo di organizzazioni come Unhcr e Oim. I diritti umani sono quindi garantiti”. Molteni nega l’evidenza, raccontata, recentemente da un duro reportage del Guardian che documenta stupri e uccisioni. Chissà se in Albania basterà citare le lettere con l’Unhcr per rassicurare in merito al rispetto dei diritti.

    ▻https://altreconomia.it/il-ruolo-dellunhcr-nei-centri-in-albania-tra-le-lettere-con-il-governo-
    #HCR #Albanie #migrations #réfugiés
    #Shengjin e #Gjader #Italie #externalisation #accord

    –-

    ajouté à la métaliste sur l’#accord entre #Italie et #Albanie pour la construction de #centres d’accueil (sic) et identification des migrants/#réfugiés sur le territoire albanais...

    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1043873

    • UNHCR denies role in identifying migrants in Albania

      During the question time of the Chamber of Deputies on October 23, Minister for Parliamentary Relations Luca Ciriani claimed UNHCR was involved in the identification of migrants in Italian centers recently opened in Albania. The UN agency has denied any such role.

      The UN’s refugee agency has denied any role in identification procedures for the migrants taken to Italian centers in Albania after an Italian minister claimed otherwise.

      “Activities for the identification of migrants eligible for border procedures in Albania was carried out onboard the pre-selected Navy ship hub Libra by a team composed of seven linguistic-cultural mediators, healthcare personnel of the International Organisation for Migration (IOM), as well as a police official assisted by three operators and UNHCR representatives,” said Minister for Parliamentary Relations Luca Ciriani in the question time of an October 23 session of Italy’s Chamber of Deputies.

      “The operations were carried out after the rescue in international waters of 79 migrants, of whom 16 met requirements for the transfer to Albania based on the guide for the detection of vulnerabilities drawn up by the interior ministry,” he continued.

      UNHCR subsequently issued a statement clarifying that it is involved in monitoring the Italy-Albania accord but not in identifying migrants.

      Minister outlines procedures in Italy and Albania

      Ciriani added: “The migrants underwent a careful medical examination by IOM healthcare personnel with full respect for their privacy and were interviewed individually in order to facilitate the finding of any sort of vulnerability, including of a psychological nature.”

      “During the sailing” of the naval vessel, he continued, “migrants were provided with both healthcare assistance onboard and detailed information in languages they understand on the procedures applied and their rights, in part thanks to the presence onboard of three IOM linguistic-cultural mediators. The migrants were also provided with thermal blankets, warm meals prepared onboard the ship, which has a hangar with an area equipped for rest and with washroom facilities.”

      The minister noted that, “on arrival in Albania, after authorization from the healthcare personnel onboard, the migrants were disembarked and healthcare screening and identification procedures were started at the hotspot. During this phase, two Bangladeshi nationals, contrary to what had been found onboard the Libra, said that they were minors. Two other Egyptian migrants, following medical examinations, were found to be unfit for life in a restricted community, confirming the accuracy of the checks carried out.”

      “For these reasons,” he concluded, “the four foreigners, assisted by an IOM mediator, were taken to Italy and inserted into the reception system.”

      ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/60795/unhcr-denies-role-in-identifying-migrants-in-albania

  • Germany : Migration commissioner proposes Rwanda deportations

    #Joachim_Stamp accused Russia and Belarus of encouraging migration to the EU as part of their “hybrid warfare.” These migrants should be sent to a third country such as Rwanda, he suggested.

    Amid Germany’s increasing debate over deportation policy, federal migration commissioner Joachim Stamp discussed the possibility of deporting migrants to Rwanda if there were difficulties returning them to their homelands.

    Speaking to the podcast Table.Briefings on Thursday, Stamp said that migrants coming to Germany via Russia and Belarus could be sent to the east African country.

    He described an influx of migrants from the two countries as part of Russian President Vladimir Putin and his Belarusian counterpart Aleksander Lukashenko’s “hybrid warfare” against the West.

    The pair are “deliberately sending migrants across the eastern border of the European Union,” Stamp said, adding that it was likely part of a plot to entice Syrian, Iraqi, and Afghan refugees to reach Europe by way of Minsk and Moscow.

    Stamp, a member of the neoliberal Free Democrats (FDP), said that the German government “could utilize the existing structures that were originally prepared for the British.”

    Successive conservative UK governments had sought a wide-ranging deal to send large numbers of asylum seekers to Rwanda. However, this plan was declared unlawful by the country’s high court and was eventually scrapped after Prime Minister Keir Starmer came to power.
    Deportation top priority for Scholz government

    Stamp added the caveat, however, that this would require Germany to amend some of its deportation laws. Currently, migrants can only be deported to a country beside their homeland if they have some connection to it, such as relatives residing there.

    Deportation has become a hot topic in Germany following a deadly knife attack in the city of Solingen by a rejected Syrian asylum-seeker who had been slated for deportation. Further complicating deportations to places like Syria and Afghanistan is that a person’s homeland has to be both willing to receive them and considered safe.

    In the wake of the Solingen attack, Chancellor Olaf Scholz has vowed to present new draft laws to speed up deportations by December.

    ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/59669/germany-migration-commissioner-proposes-rwanda-deportations

    #Allemagne #Rwanda #externalisation #migrations #réfugiés #asile
    #guerre_hybride #Russie #Ukraine

    –-

    ajouté à la métaliste sur les tentatives de différentes pays européens d’#externalisation non seulement des contrôles frontaliers (►https://seenthis.net/messages/731749), mais aussi de la #procédure_d'asile dans des #pays_tiers :
    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/900122

  • Centri migranti Albania, sindacati della penitenziaria contro il governo: in Italia caos carceri ma si inviano agenti nei “campi di prigionia”

    I centri italiani per migranti costruiti in Albania e voluti dal governo di Giorgia Meloni continuano a far discutere. Nelle ultime ore, in particolare, a causa dell’uso di agenti italiani della penitenziaria pronti a essere dispiegati a vario titolo nelle strutture di Shengjin e Gjader. Alcuni sindacati hanno infatti protestato contro le scelte dell’esecutivo con un comunicato ufficiale, sottolineando come al momento, visto il caos totale all’interno delle carceri italiane, dovrebbe essere altre le priorità in merito all’utilizzo di risorse.
    Centri migranti Albania, sindacati della penitenziaria contro il governo

    A diffondere un comunicato sono stati la Federazione sindacale del Coordinamento sindacale penitenziario insieme alla Confederazione autonoma italiana polizia penitenziaria. Due sindacati che si dicono basiti “dalla notizia del provvedimento con cui l’Esecutivo avrebbe deciso l’invio in Albania, per un accordo internazionale tra i leader dei due Paesi di circa cinquanta unità del Corpo della polizia penitenziaria dei diversi ruoli e qualifiche con trattamento di missione Internazionale e con regole di ingaggio del tutto discutibili e non condivise con le organizzazioni sindacali”. Cinquanta agenti che quindi andranno a lavorare sull’altra sponda dell’Adriatico.

    Il problema, però, è che mentre il governo continua a porre attenzione e risorse sul piano Albania, la situazione nelle carceri italiane è sempre più emergenziale. Un aspetto rimarcato dai sindacati che criticano la missione “quando in Italia si registra una popolazione detenuta di oltre 62mila persone ristrette contro una capienza di 44mila posti letto e un organico di polizia al di sotto di 20mila unità, con 10.700 agenti feriti e diverse rivolte, tentativi di sommosse, autolesionismi a centinaia, suicidi 67 detenuti e 7 poliziotti“. La priorità per le organizzazioni di penitenziaria dovrebbe essere il quadro interno, non i centri in Albania in una “struttura che ricorda inquietantemente un campo di prigionia. E ora si parla addirittura di inviare i baschi verdi a presidiare questo complesso”.

    L’accordo Italia Albania sui centri per migranti

    I due centri sono stati previsti e costruiti dopo l’accordo tra il governo italiano di Meloni e quello albanese di Edi Rama firmato il 6 novembre del 2023. Le strutture sono gestite e controllate dall’Italia nel territorio albanese e serviranno – almeno sulla carta – per l’esame delle domande di asilo dei richiedenti asilo. I migranti che vi saranno trasferiti saranno quelli salvati in mare da navi miliari italiane. I due centri, quello nel porto di Shengjin e quello di Gjader, avranno in teoria due ruoli diversi: il primo dedicato alle procedure di sbarco e identificazione, mentre il secondo al trattamento delle domande e alla contemporanea accoglienza. Secondo quanto stabilito da Roma e Tirana, i migranti trasferiti in Albania potranno essere al massimo 3000 al mese, per un totale di 36mila all’anno. Il tutto per un costo enorme, potenzialmente pari a 635 milioni in cinque anni. Ad aggiungersi alla bilancia dei costi rispetto ai vantaggi, c’è anche il fatto che della cifra totale, come si vede in un rapporto di Openpolis, più di un terzo – cioè quasi 252 milioni – è prevista per le trasferte dei funzionari italiani. Una voce di spesa che sarebbe stata ben diversa in caso di costruzione dei centri in Italia.
    Molteni: protocollo con Albania utile e moderno, un modello per la gestione dei flussi

    Chi continua a lodare il piano Albania è Nicola Molteni. In un’intervista a La Stampa, il sottosegretario all’Interno della Lega ha parlato di quanto sia importante l’accordo con Tirana per Roma: “Credo che il protocollo con l’Albania sia utile, necessario e moderno. Un’iniziativa che sui territori extra Ue sarà il futuro. È un accordo di deterrenza per le partenze e di alleggerimento delle nostre strutture approvato da 15 Paesi europei. La struttura in Albania sarà il modello per la gestione dei flussi migratori”.

    ▻https://www.ilriformista.it/centri-migranti-albania-sindacati-penitenziaria-contro-governo-italia-c
    #Albanie #Italie #externalisation #syndicats #migrations #réfugiés #asile #polizia_penitenziaria

    –-

    ajouté à la métaliste sur l’#accord entre #Italie et #Albanie pour la construction de #centres d’accueil (sic) et identification des migrants/#réfugiés sur le territoire albanais...

    ►https://seenthis.net/messages/1043873

    • ’Migrant centers in Albania like prison camps’ say Italian unions

      Italian prison officers’ unions have protested the deployment of 50 correctional officers to Albania to guard new migrant holding facilities, stating that they are being “sent on a mission with rules that were not shared.”

      On August 31, two organizations representing Italy’s penitentiary police — the Italian Autonomous Confederation of Penitentiary Police and the Officers’ Union Coordination — released a statement expressing that their members were “stunned by the report of a measure” in which the government decided to send around 50 penitentiary police units of various roles and qualifications to Albania. This deployment is part of an international mission under an agreement between the leaders of Italy and Albania, involving controversial rules of engagement that have not been discussed with the unions.

      Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and her Albanian counterpart Edi Rama have signed an agreement to build two migrant hosting facilities in Albania for the detention of migrants who attempt to reach Italy by sea while their asylum claims are examined.

      The centers, which are slated to open this month, are to be paid for by the Italian cabinet.

      Difficulties experienced by penitentiary police in Italy

      The mission occurs “when Italy is registering a population of over 62,000 detainees against a capacity of 44,000 beds and a police corps lacking 20,000 officers, with 10,700 wounded officers and many riots, protest attempts, hundreds of episodes of self-harm and the suicides of 67 detainees and seven police officers,” the statement said.

      The two unions added that “what appears to be taking shape in Albania is a facility that disturbingly reminds us of prison camps.”

      “And now there is talk of sending the green berets”, members of an anti-terror finance police unit, “to patrol this complex,” they noted.

      The agreement between Italy and Albania

      The agreement between Rome and Tirana, signed on November 6 last year, is based on an old cooperation treaty between the two countries and provides for the construction of two repatriation centers for migrants — managed and controlled by Italy on Albanian territory — for the speedy process of asylum requests.

      Part of the migrants rescued at sea by Italian Navy vessels will be transferred to Albania, a non-EU country considered as safe by Italy.

      ▻https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/59571/migrant-centers-in-albania-like-prison-camps-say-italian-unions